https://gloria.tv/article/2wSjVmbaPD7M3q4Ea2YaYSioB

SSPX Father: Wrong Arguments against Henry Sire’s „Dictator Pope“

Father Franz Schmidberger, a former superior general of the Society of St Pius X (SSPX) and now rector of the German seminary, has criticised Henry Sire’s famous The Dictator Pope in his weekly email to priests (November 5).

One of his arguments, "After reading the revelations one wonders: do they strengthen my faith in the Church and my love for it? This is probably the case only for very few readers."

Schmidberger adds, “Not the exposure of the scandals in Rome will save us, but the fidelity to the Church's full tradition and the to Old Latin Mass.”

On the basis of similar arguments ɧoɱosɛҳųαƖ, liturgical and doctrinal scandals have been allowed to grow in the Church.

#newsMgqqewcrly

Schmidberger adds, “Not the exposure of the scandals in Rome will save us, but the fidelity to the Church's full tradition and the to Old Latin Mass.”

The "exposure of the scandals" helps one see that Vatican II's humanism etc. has caused these problems.

False dichotomy?!

I think what Fr. S. might be referring to is that political scandals, which The Dictator Pope exposes, are not the real issue; the real issue is doctrine.

.

Quote from: klasG4e on Yesterday at 05:58:23 PM

Quote

Schmidberger adds, “Not the exposure of the scandals in Rome will save us, but the fidelity to the Church's full tradition and the to Old Latin Mass.”

.

The "exposure of the scandals" helps one see that Vatican II's humanism etc. has caused these problems.

.
Yes, indeed!
.
Hiding one's head in the sand like an ostritch won't save us either. Better for scandals to be made known than to pretend they don't exist.
.
Fr. Schmidberger makes himself look like he thinks pandering to the Vat.II errors is somehow a necessity for normalization at any cost.

Father Franz Schmidberger, a former superior general of the Society of St Pius X (SSPX) and now rector of the German seminary, has criticised Henry Sire’s famous The Dictator Pope in his weekly email to priests (November 5).

One of his arguments, "After reading the revelations one wonders: do they strengthen my faith in the Church and my love for it? This is probably the case only for very few readers."

Schmidberger adds, “Not the exposure of the scandals in Rome will save us, but the fidelity to the Church's full tradition and the to Old Latin Mass.”

On the basis of similar arguments ɧoɱosɛҳųαƖ, liturgical and doctrinal scandals have been allowed to grow in the Church.

That is all he said, three quotes?

"fidelity to the Church's full tradition"  Say what?!

https://angeluspress.org/products/the-realist-guide-to-religion-and-science

By their deeds you shall know them.