In the limited recording introducing the presentation given by Fr. Themann, Fr. Beck gave a marriage analogy, equating a person who incorrectly believes that his spouse is cheating on him; imagining unfaithfulness around every corner, causing his own demise, the demise of his marriage, and the ruin of his children, to those who listen to "The Resistance" and falsely imagines Menzingen betraying the SSPX around every corner. He states that this is very dangerous.
I agree that having a fertile imagination, like Othello, can drive a man crazy. Unfortunately, the written proof of Menzingen slide toward modernism and modernist Rome is not imagined. It is clear for all to read on DICI, their other websites, printed publications, and most certainly in their actions! The order previously printed in “Cor Unum” to turn off the bulldozer against modernism is clear for all to read.
I ask Fr. Beck this however, what if after forty years of marriage, your spouse begins to tidy up the house so as not to offend a strange man? What if she starts to change the way she speaks and the manner in which she conducts herself for fear that this strange man, a man who is a notorious scoundrel, will lose interest in her? What if she throws everyone out of your house who comments about her odd behavior? What if you find secret love letters, letters that clearly show that she has betrayed everything you and your marriage has stood for, for over four decades? What if these letters even bare her signature? What if even after you find these hidden letters, letters she had never intended for you to ever see, she showed no remorse? Worse yet, what if she started to announce to the entire family that there was nothing really wrong with these letters (just read them with rose colored glasses)? I ask you, how much more dangerous is it to the marriage and children to pretend that no betrayal has taken place? How much more dangerous is it to make excuses for these letters and deny the signature that is on them? How much more dangerous is it to jump to this woman’s defense when she admits no betrayal? Isn’t every one morally obliged before the throne of God to rise up and warn the husband? Shouldn’t everyone try to protect the children? Do not the actions of the wife require restitution? Are those who remain silent committing a sin of omission?