Spirituality vs. Dogma  can very easily become Feelings vs. Reasoning when rather than God's Grace being involved, it is self-interests that direct ones actions. For example, a person can embrace the Novus Ordo because of all of the laxity which it permits (communion with no confessions, annulments, marriage with few children, positions of authority). Likewise, an SSPX priest can move up in position if he goes along with the Neo-SSPX superiors. The SSPX parishioner can be "normalized" with Rome and not have to defend himself against his non-SSPX relatives.

If one is directed by God's Grace and not their own self-interest, they will seek to learn truth, which is exactly what dogma is, and they will avoid error, heresy, and recognize it. They may not be able to debate about it, but they will recognize error, if they are in God's Grace.

I think it was Pope Pius IX who said that a bottle of wine, that is 99% perfect fine wine, if you add one drop of arsenic, will kill you just the same as a bottle of poison. Pius X said that the modernist will say something that is 100% orthodox, and then teach heresy in one line. When Saul, the persecutor of the apostles, was struck by lightning and thrown off his horse and converted to St. Paul, not one apostle trusted him till after a time he proved himself converted by his deeds and miracles. How do  these three comments tie together?

The answer is that the hierarchy in Rome and the world is poison, they are modernists, who poison people with heresy, they kill souls. And like St. Paul, they can't be trusted. It matters little if they are 99% orthodox (which I doubt any Novus Ordo bishop or priest is), they will kill your soul just the same!

Have to go.