Quote from: Elsa Zardini

Ja! Ja! Seriously, Incred: Where is the letter of expulsion? Has it been posted somewhere? Many thanks!

This was posted at http://mauricepinay.blogspot.com/2011/10/letter-from-bishop-fellay-to-bishop.html . I can't vouch for its authenticity.

Letter from Bishop Fellay to Bishop Williamson

23 September, 2011

Your Excellency,

I would be happy to invite you to the SSPX Superiors’ meeting to be held in Albano early in October, as the nature and composition of the meeting has been somewhat changed because of current events. I would also be happy to send you a text from Rome to which they want a reply. However, I find myself obliged to attach conditions to each of these points.

Firstly, as to the text, I ask of you an oath in writing that you will communicate to nobody either the text or its content. Too often in the past you have lacked discretion, so I am obliged to submit you to a procedure of this kind, which I am not happy to have to do.

Secondly, as to the meeting in Albano, I can only invite you to attend insofar as you stop publishing Eleison Comments. You have already been given the reason several times, as you have been given the order to stop. You considered that for the sake of the preaching and defence of the Faith you needed pay no attention, on the pretext that nobody had the right to stop a bishop from fulfilling his duty to preach and defend the Faith. But such preaching and defence of the Faith are inserted in concrete circuмstances which may well call for superiors to intervene. Besides, no other bishop of the SSPX publishes a circular letter and considers himself thereby hindered from expressing himself.

Moreover the consequences of your attitude are harmful to the SSPX: you ooze distrust towards SSPX headquarters and the Superior General. You cannot help yourself communicating this feeling to those around you. No revolution could do a better job of undermining authority… and this you do in the name of a supposed possible betrayal on the part of the Superior General… That is very serious.

Especially when a certain number of indications show that your action is not confined to theory:

1 To an Argentinian priest from the Novus Ordo who asks for your advice, you recommend that he should not join the SSPX.

2 To an American layman you write that the apostasy of the mainstream Church is farther advanced than that of the SSPX. How can you write such things, false and unjust, against the Society of which you are still a member?

3 There exists in Anglo-saxon circles a network of infiltrators of the SSPX preparing a break-away. You are put forward as the head of this movement, you are the friend of its leaders and you are playing their game.

And you talk to us of being double tongued! As for the unity of the SSPX, the one most putting it in danger is yourself, your Excellency! Always in the name of defense of the Faith. In such a grave moment as the confrontation now taking place between ourselves and the Holy See, the outcome of which will be decisive for our own future and not without consequences for the entire Church, I ask you then, once more, to remain silent until further orders. If you were to refuse to heed this directive, it would mean both your not being invited to the Albano meeting and the starting of the canonical procedure leading to exclusion from the SSPX. So I await your reply.

All of this is most sad, and it has nothing to do with the confrontation just mentioned, whatever you may think. The loss of one of its bishops is one of the worst things that could happen to the SSPX. It depends entirely on you to spare it such a misfortune. Do believe, your Excellency, in my fervent prayers to the Sacred Heart of Jesus,
BpF.

I can't say I am surprised that people are asking about this Letter now or hearing about it for first time. All par for the course in SSPX circles.

Quote from: John Grace

It's fair to say most Districts now have a Resistance Chapel/Mass Centre. ..... With a resistance chapel now in most Districts and countries, I would have to question why laity remain with the SSPX.

In all fairness, you must remember that the US is a wee bit bigger than Ireland, so to say we have a Resistance Chapel doesn't mean that it is within reasonable driving distance for everyone.

Yes, it's nice to know that Ireland has a Resistance chapel.  

The closest thing to that I have near me is an Irish pub where
they play Irish folk music.  Now, while the music is nice and
very enjoyable, and even for someone like me who has never
been to the Emerald Isle, it is in knowing Irish people that
the enchantment of the Isle has been brought to me.  

Oh, I have flown over Ireland twice.  It's very green down there,
from 30,000 feet up.

Time was Ireland supplied priests and nuns for planet earth. Now,
what we see and hear is an occasional brogue, a drinking song,
a step dance, or an Australian Irish ballad, like "If We Only Had
Old Ireland Over Here."

BTW you can read all about it over HERE.

We should be encouraging Resistance Mass centers, for there
are many people who might be willing to attend if they only knew
of one nearby.  But as it is, for numerous people in the western
USA, it is a 5 hour drive or more, to the closest one.  So it's an
all day event, and the fuel tank eats up $120.00 if you get 20
MPG.  Some cars get less than that.  At some point, it's cheaper
to fly an airplane to Mass.  At least it's more time efficient.

We have a lot more so-called independent chapels, and we have
CMRI too.  So for the moment, we scrape by..

..while the hungry beast of the Apocalypse breathes down our
collective necks.




Sometimes it seems to be a fire-breathing dragon......................







. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . St. George, pray for us.