Why would anyone care to defend him on a Resistance website?
There are Sedes and Indults here so I figured its possible he had defenders here as well.
I know that some people like to "rise above it all", come up with new terminology, try to create ground-breaking threads, and in general feel like they're ultra-special.
Unfortunately for this thread, it's nothing new. Rather than being a ground-breaking genius, you come across more as a retard that's been hiding under a rock for the past 2 years.
Why don't you familiarize yourself with the forum for a few days -- look at past posts in the SSPX Resistance subforum. We have thousands of posts there going back to 2012 when the whole thing started.
Sorry, you can't just conveniently ignore all the reams of evidence that have been posted here in the past 2 years. As a matter of fact, those who passionately (against all evidence) choose to ignore such history are PRECISELY those who aren't welcome here. I'm not going to host those kind of fanboys and blind idiots on CathInfo.
We've had dozens of "+Fellay defenders" since 2012 and none of them did a good job at all.
Worthy opponents might keep me on my toes, but I won't ban them for that. In fact, if you want to be special you're welcome to try to debunk the Resistance. No one has succeeded yet. :)
I can understand criticizing Fr. Pfeiffer (who is admittedly quite controversial, even among Resistance supporters), Fr. Pfeiffer's lay helper(s), the outlook for success for the Resistance, etc. but you MUST acknowledge the very real facts which have been put out there in the past 2 years. Very
real and
concrete changes have happened in the SSPX in the past 2 years.
Anyone who thinks the Resistance is nothing more than several thousand SSPX-supporters ("oh, they weren't real supporters, but leeches at the various chapels, and sedevacantists") who spontaneously decided to give up on the spiritual life all at once in May 2012 -- even though they were scattered all around the world and don't have contact with each other -- I don't know what to say.
Anyone that foolish is beyond words. That's why they're not welcome on CathInfo.Anyone who keeps harping on neo-SSPX propaganda talking points, anyone who uses the classic Communist "repeat a lie often enough, and it becomes the truth" tactic, and anyone who ignores evidence injected into a discussion as if it wasn't there is in reality
an agent, a troll and quite ban-worthy. Such a person is not here to discuss, nor is such a person interested in discussion. Such a one is only here to blindly promote an agenda.
What +Fellay (and his followers -- this part is very important) is doing to the SSPX and those loyal to its mission is indefensible.