B. Faure attacks technology.Cathinfo members will be interested to learn that Bishop Faure in his bulletin of the SAJM has made clear the way he wants he seminarians formed; to turn their nose up at the "electronic world".
Here is the quote from his bulletin : (speaking to his seminarians) "You will be separated from the world and its' concupiscences. Particularly you will separate yourself from the electronic world, which refuses to accept dependence on the Good Lord; Modern man fights against his Creator by destroying his interior life and soul, and having a totally profane and exterior behavior" ("Seminary news" - Winter 2018, SAJM -
https://seminaireavrille.org/)
Positive interpretation: The Bishop is simply warning us against technology addiction, and encouraging us to have a deeper prayer life. What could be wrong with this?
Negative interpretation (and the true one); The reality is that the practical manifestation of this is discouraging faithful from looking at the internet and particularly forums, which some priests say are gossip dens, so that the faithful may not come to know the truth about certain issues.
Priests have to be in the world but not of it. Discouraging them from using technology will not help them to be as cunning as serpents, as Our Lord asks us to be.
The problem is the wording of his remarks. Technology is not evil in itself. Like everything in this life it must be limited, and excess of anything is a sin. Certainly we want our children to be well formed and not start "swiping left" when reading books as some do now. But we need to make good use of technology, especially where it is the last place where the truth can be found when it has been banned everywhere else.
If the Bishop had wanted to say that he wanted his seminarians to avoid worldliness, then he should have said avoid worldly websites. Even twitter can be used well, if done properly, so it is excessive to tell them to "separate from the electronic world", as in practically all of it. No doubt he will claim this is not what he means. However his words are too vague to be interpreted in the right way.
His words can be too easily interpreted as an attack on technology itself, rather than principles (worldly ones), the latter being what he intended.
Some other notes: The "electronic world" is vague in other ways also. He could be meaning worldly people on the internet. But if this is the case, the same can be said of any other medium. There is no need to single out the internet more than books or newspapers, or simply people we meet in real life. Clearly people on Cathinfo are not refusing to accept dependence on God, and clearly internet technology in itself does not do this. It is bad people who use it who refuse this dependence.
By putting "electronic" before "world", rather than saying "the wordly in the electronic domain", people think of technology being bad, rather than people being bad. Technology is a part of life, and we will meet bad people everywhere. The "world" will have to be avoided everywhere. It is no more the case in technology than elsewhere. Good use and discipline must be made of it, as in all things, but that is not the same as avoiding it altogether.
- By a faithful, but concerned member of the resistance