I read it too, and it sounds like a man who has an axe to grind against Bishop Faure, despite all the flowery language.
Oh yes, he dresses it up real nice, with random footnotes all over the place. He says all the right things, copy-pasted out of the Lives of the Saints -- anyone can do that. He probably spent a lot of time fine-tuning and putting the final polish on this hit piece. Everything he says though is unsubstantiated hearsay, all of which (conveniently) can't be proven.
EDIT: And a lot of it is quite easily DISproven. See the post on the next page by CentroAmerica talking about Algerian Jєωs. It's a fact that Bp. Faure is of French descent, and his physical features bear that out.
Of course you'll also note Fr. Juan (the author of the hit piece) says *nothing* about the present day. He doesn't extend his arms and say, "Just look! Need I say anything?" about Bp. Faure's actions and behavior today. That's because there is nothing at all to criticize, much less reproach +Faure with.
In other words, look at the facts: +Faure is opposing modernism, the new direction of the SSPX, he isn't fighting with fellow Resisters or causing any black eyes or strife (hurting the Resistance cause), he is running a seminary to form the next generation of Traditional Catholic priests, he is about to go on a 3 week trip in North America to give conferences and administer Confirmations to all those who need them. Doesn't sound like a destroyer to me.
Even the "two others" who supposedly were with Fr. Juan (the PDF's author) on this, aren't saying anything, to the present day! Fr. Juan even admits this in his letter. He "adjures" them to come forward, but for some reason they're not coming forward. What, are they not in love with Holy Mother Church like he is? Maybe because they aren't willing to perjure themselves, along with him?
I like how he came up with an excuse why he didn't say anything until now. We're talking 30 years! Again, "how convenient".
Where has this man been until now "for the good of Holy Mother Church"? He waited until the Resistance was in the early, vulnerable stages to strike another public blow at Bishop Faure? My suspicions are high about this one.
I think CentroAmerica, who knows more about he situation in South America since he lives there, is dead-on about this one. The sedevacantists, masons, etc., would have a lot to gain by hitting their "competition" when they're down like this. Basically they want to nip the Resistance in the bud. Few people have even met Bishop Faure yet. They're shrewd little devils, I'll give them that.
And I'll point out again: Bishop Faure is about to go on a huge 3-week tour of North America, stopping at many places for Mass, conference and/or Confirmations. Wouldn't they love to poison the well before this trip and see if they can't just stop a bunch of people from going -- and getting to know the REAL Bishop Faure (the devout, excellent bishop defending Tradition)!
We have to take this fancy little PDF *in context* of everything else we already know. It's only part of the big picture.
I this case, I think it's much more likely that this unknown priest is a bad guy, than that Bishop Faure is a bad guy.