Send CathInfo's owner Matthew a gift from his Amazon wish list:
https://www.amazon.com/hz/wishlist/ls/25M2B8RERL1UO

Author Topic: Attend the SSPX? Read this.  (Read 14093 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Attend the SSPX? Read this.
« Reply #40 on: August 26, 2015, 01:23:00 PM »
Quote from: trento
If I recall correctly, even Archbishop Lefebvre attended a Novus Ordo wedding of a relative...

Did he attend a Novus Ordo wedding? I thought I read somewhere that he attended his mother's Novus Ordo funeral, but I may be wrong.

Attend the SSPX? Read this.
« Reply #41 on: August 26, 2015, 03:15:19 PM »
Quote from: trento
Quote from: J.Paul
Quote from: St Gertrude
Matthew, several years  ago, a member of my extended family died and her children had a NO "funeral mass" in the chapel of the nursing home where she had lived. An SSPX priest I know said to go out of respect for our family, but to not participate in any way, so I took my missal, sat in an inconspicuous place, silently read my missal and silently prayed a rosary for the repose of her soul.  I had not been near a NO church in many years, and the whole thing just repulsed me.  It was more like a party than a Catholic funeral.  The saddest part of it all was that she loved Tradition and never went to a NO mass in her life.   :facepalm:


More bad advice from the SSPX.  One should never attend a sacrilege out of concerns of human respect. There is a much higher principle involved in this.

Out of Catholic Charity in such cases one should not even consider a Novus Ordo funeral, but rather attend the graveside internment, pray the Catholic prayers for the dead, and say a Rosary for the repose of that soul.  In this way you fulfill your Christian duty and do not violate the Sensus Catholicus and the principles which come from it.

If I recall correctly, even Archbishop Lefebvre attended a Novus Ordo wedding of a relative...


It is my understanding that the 1917 Canon Law allowed for Catholics to attend non-Catholic weddings and funeral services so long as they did not actively participate.


Attend the SSPX? Read this.
« Reply #42 on: August 26, 2015, 04:00:49 PM »
Quote from: trento
Quote from: J.Paul
Quote from: St Gertrude
Matthew, several years  ago, a member of my extended family died and her children had a NO "funeral mass" in the chapel of the nursing home where she had lived. An SSPX priest I know said to go out of respect for our family, but to not participate in any way, so I took my missal, sat in an inconspicuous place, silently read my missal and silently prayed a rosary for the repose of her soul.  I had not been near a NO church in many years, and the whole thing just repulsed me.  It was more like a party than a Catholic funeral.  The saddest part of it all was that she loved Tradition and never went to a NO mass in her life.   :facepalm:


More bad advice from the SSPX.  One should never attend a sacrilege out of concerns of human respect. There is a much higher principle involved in this.

Out of Catholic Charity in such cases one should not even consider a Novus Ordo funeral, but rather attend the graveside internment, pray the Catholic prayers for the dead, and say a Rosary for the repose of that soul.  In this way you fulfill your Christian duty and do not violate the Sensus Catholicus and the principles which come from it.

If I recall correctly, even Archbishop Lefebvre attended a Novus Ordo wedding of a relative...


If true, that does not speak well of the Archbishop. His alleged compromise does not excuse anyone who considers doing the same thing.

Attend the SSPX? Read this.
« Reply #43 on: August 26, 2015, 04:07:16 PM »
Quote from: 2Vermont
Quote from: trento
Quote from: J.Paul
Quote from: St Gertrude
Matthew, several years  ago, a member of my extended family died and her children had a NO "funeral mass" in the chapel of the nursing home where she had lived. An SSPX priest I know said to go out of respect for our family, but to not participate in any way, so I took my missal, sat in an inconspicuous place, silently read my missal and silently prayed a rosary for the repose of her soul.  I had not been near a NO church in many years, and the whole thing just repulsed me.  It was more like a party than a Catholic funeral.  The saddest part of it all was that she loved Tradition and never went to a NO mass in her life.   :facepalm:


More bad advice from the SSPX.  One should never attend a sacrilege out of concerns of human respect. There is a much higher principle involved in this.

Out of Catholic Charity in such cases one should not even consider a Novus Ordo funeral, but rather attend the graveside internment, pray the Catholic prayers for the dead, and say a Rosary for the repose of that soul.  In this way you fulfill your Christian duty and do not violate the Sensus Catholicus and the principles which come from it.

If I recall correctly, even Archbishop Lefebvre attended a Novus Ordo wedding of a relative...


It is my understanding that the 1917 Canon Law allowed for Catholics to attend non-Catholic weddings and funeral services so long as they did not actively participate.


That is a pretty thin justification to attend the Novus Ordo. A Protestant service is nothing, it has no meaning or power. The Novus Ordo on the other hand is a mockery of Our Lord's Sacred action and a sacrilege. The 1917 code never imagined such a thing to be possible and canon law is not Divine law which forbids it.

Attend the SSPX? Read this.
« Reply #44 on: August 26, 2015, 04:23:08 PM »
Quote from: J.Paul
Quote from: 2Vermont
Quote from: trento
Quote from: J.Paul
Quote from: St Gertrude
Matthew, several years  ago, a member of my extended family died and her children had a NO "funeral mass" in the chapel of the nursing home where she had lived. An SSPX priest I know said to go out of respect for our family, but to not participate in any way, so I took my missal, sat in an inconspicuous place, silently read my missal and silently prayed a rosary for the repose of her soul.  I had not been near a NO church in many years, and the whole thing just repulsed me.  It was more like a party than a Catholic funeral.  The saddest part of it all was that she loved Tradition and never went to a NO mass in her life.   :facepalm:


More bad advice from the SSPX.  One should never attend a sacrilege out of concerns of human respect. There is a much higher principle involved in this.

Out of Catholic Charity in such cases one should not even consider a Novus Ordo funeral, but rather attend the graveside internment, pray the Catholic prayers for the dead, and say a Rosary for the repose of that soul.  In this way you fulfill your Christian duty and do not violate the Sensus Catholicus and the principles which come from it.

If I recall correctly, even Archbishop Lefebvre attended a Novus Ordo wedding of a relative...


It is my understanding that the 1917 Canon Law allowed for Catholics to attend non-Catholic weddings and funeral services so long as they did not actively participate.


That is a pretty thin justification to attend the Novus Ordo. A Protestant service is nothing, it has no meaning or power. The Novus Ordo on the other hand is a mockery of Our Lord's Sacred action and a sacrilege. The 1917 code never imagined such a thing to be possible and canon law is not Divine law which forbids it.


I see what you are saying but what is the Divine Law that forbids it?