"that you and Fr. Hewko believe you are the only real Catholic priests left in the world. "
He makes a good point here.
If they aren't the only real priests, then who else do they think is valid/faithful? And most importantly, are there any BISHOPS?
I know some Trad priests who chose to be "uber-independent" -- just saying Mass for a group or two of Trads and having no connection at all to other priests, bishops, or organizations. But what Fr. Pfeiffer is doing is that much worse -- much more insane -- because he pretends to have a seminary. If you're going to be a maverick independent priest (with no bishop superior because "crisis"), then at least you can't have a seminary.
How can Fr. P pretend that running a seminary is God's will, when it's clearly NOT God's will, as evidenced by Fr. P's current lack of bishop? Fr. P is the one who claims the 4 Resistance bishops aren't faithful, good enough, etc. Ok, that's your opinion. Then from where Fr. P stands, God hasn't provided a bishop.
Doesn't he understand how God's providence works? How it is manifest in this world? It is manifest by what happens in reality.
If John believes that he's called to be married, but can't manage to find a decent Catholic woman by age 50, then don't you suppose John was simply WRONG about God's will for him? 100 out of 100 spiritual directors would say YES.
Likewise, if a young man believed he had a priestly vocation, but he was rejected from every seminary he entered, and then lost his right thumb in a factory accident, don't you suppose God's will is being manifest here -- overriding the subjective opinions swimming around in the young man's head regarding his vocation?
Personal feelings aren't God's will. God's will is made known by the situation in reality.