Overturning Roe v Wade is not only a huge win for US Catholics. It is also victory for Catholics and prolifers around the globe.

  There was no "huge win".  Dobbs was an unmitigated disaster.

  There was no "huge win".  Dobbs was an unmitigated disaster.

Sigh. My friend, for once in your life, have a little humility, give up your preconceived notions, and actually read what pro-abort liberals are saying. If you were right, and it was as you say, pro-abort liberals would be dancing in the street and rejoicing over Dobbs. Rather they are in tears, lamenting their loss, and our victory. I am being kind in saying "our" when in point of fact that victory strictly speaking only belongs to those who voted for and supported Trump-Pence and now support Trump-Vance in completing the task. Here's to praying/hoping you awake from your blindness and do the right thing in time. If not, others will, and the pro life cause will move full steam ahead.

Next stop: a 15 week federal ban. 2 more pro life supreme court justices. After that, a 6 week federal ban. 2 more pro life supreme court justices. Then a life at conception act, personhood amendment, and supreme court unilaterally declaring unborn children are full legal persons and thus enjoy complete right to life under the 14th amendment. 

Sigh. My friend, for once in your life, have a little humility, give up your preconceived notions, and actually read what pro-abort liberals are saying.

Use your brain evey once in a while, would you?  Apart from the practical matter that shows abortions continuing at the same pace (same numbers) after Dobbs, Dobbs is a complete disaster because it implicitly holds that unborn children do not have an unalienable God-given right to life, since, if they did, it would be protected under the Constitution and no state could legislate it away.  SCOTUS had an opportunity (with a majority "Catholic") to declare the actual Right to Life.  So now it's going to make it THAT MUCH MORE difficult to outlaw abortion.  Now we'll need to get justices that have the cajones to overturn Dobbs and take that "right" way from states to lesgislate away unborn life, which will never happen, naturally speaking ... until God intervenes.  Of course, it'll never be outlawed in the Blue State, and in fact the Leftists redoubled their efforts so that states like Ohio that were on the verge of outlawing abortion somehow now established abortion as a "right" in the Constitution.  And if it actually becomes a problem for some Leftists in Red States (and they haven't been more careful to use the abortion pill immediately after engaging in activities that might require an abortion), and if they can't simply travel to a state where it's legal (or their employer won't pay for it), they can always move to a Blue State.

You guys have to use your brains and realize that ideas and principles matter, not just the outcome but the reasons for the outcome.  When you have various politicians (including Trump/Vance) claiming that abortion should be banned except in certain cases (life of mother, incese, rape), you're actually surrendering the basis for your argument.  If those are lives, the fact that the mother was victimized by rape and incest doesn't make it so we can exstinguish those lives.  When you say junk like that, you're implicitly declaring that those unborn children are not lives and do not have the right to live.

When you surrender your principles for a dubious short-term tactical gain (and the tactical gain here was dubious at best), you're losing the war by giving way on your principles.  Every single time.  This is where your ends justifies the means and utilitarian / moral relativism manifests itself for being the trash that it is ... and you're also compromising Catholicism in the process.

SCOTUS had an opportunity (with a majority "Catholic") to declare the actual Right to Life.

While I'm sure it felt satisfying to put "Catholic" in scare quotes, that does not accomplish anything. Overturning Roe enabled 14 states to effectively ban abortion. That's a huge victory. Now, sufficient numbers also need to be convinced of the truth of the pro-life cause, and then more states will ban or restrict abortion. 2 more pro-life supreme court justices are certainly possible in the next term, and probably 4 or 5 in the next 8-12 years. Once there are sufficient pro life justices on the court, and abortion cases certainly will keep being referred to the supreme court, so there will be no dearth of opportunity, then the supreme court can declare unborn children are full legal persons entitled to the right to life guaranteed to all persons by the 14th amendment. 14 states. 14th amendment. Keep it in mind. Thats the pro life strategy of Trump supporters. I'm still waiting for anything resembling a "strategy" from those saying "let's do nothing for the next 4 years at least, or maybe even 8 or 12 yrs". Is that a strategy? It has zero chance of success. Ours has a much better one, and it shows the gamble of supporting Trump in 16 paid off.

Go on the record. What was your stance about supporting Trump in 16 and 20? Was it the same "lets do nothing" as in 2024? We will come back and review your stance and its results in 2028, 2032 and 2036. You can review mine too. My stance was to support Trump in 2016, because I knew 2 to 3 supreme court justices were likely in his term, as indeed proved to be the case, and also to support Trump in 2020, because I knew Roe v Wade would surely be overturned if he got back into office. Turns out, even without him needing to get back in, RvW was overturned anyway. Lets work together, friends, we pro lifers are on the same side and should be working for the same end goal.

  There was no "huge win".  Dobbs was an unmitigated disaster.

You are absolutely right, especially because most metro areas in a state where it is illegal... border a state where it is not. So there is nothing stopping people, most of whom in those areas make their living in one state and live in another where the laws are different.