Maybe BC3000 is referring to the larger social context in our country and the world? He would be right that to start objecting to her on the basis of her being female would be political death. It is what it is.
Essentially, yes. I agree with Ladislaus that in a Catholic society, an anti abortion male would be chosen, period. But I'm not going to object to Barrett given the sort of society we live in, Nor am I going to hold Trump, a liberal leaning Presbyterian, to Catholic principles.
The only thing I could think of is that a female justice even violates natural law, but Im not certain of this, and even if so, there are bigger fish to fry, so to speak.
So I agree idealistically but I realize the game that's being played.