I just heard the clip (I learned today of a way to get Global News Channel from Canada, among others, on Roku) and it is a classic mental reservation.
Only problem is, the world outside of Catholicism doesn't draw that distinction, and they just regard such a mental reservation as a lie, IOW, "intent to deceive = lie". They couldn't care less that we seek to find a way not to divulge information without actually speaking contrary to our own minds. There is talk of Rodgers being suspended.
I really get tired of dealing with non-Catholics sometimes, but alas, unless I would enter a monastery or something, there's no way around that.
(And I would have to find some way of having my marriage declared null, I'd have to provide for my son's support and my mother's care, and the big kicker, I'd have to give up my worldly goods. Kind of like the guy who had to walk away in Scripture?)