What do you think becomes of the faithful NOers?  By "faithful" I mean those few who attend NO Mass every Sunday, go to NO Confession, do not use birth control, believe in the Real Presence, fast on the required days, etc.

Yeah, I'm confused by the question.

What do you think becomes of the faithful NOers?  By "faithful" I mean those few who attend NO Mass every Sunday, go to NO Confession, do not use birth control, believe in the Real Presence, fast on the required days, etc.

Some of them are genuinely good people who are simply trying to do the right thing as best they know how. I doubt that God will judge them too harshly, given the diabolical disorientation of today. Of course, I also believe that NO sacraments are valid (at least most of the time). I would assume most sedes wouldn't agree with my opinion. But, God won't judge them based on any of our opinions....

What about faithful Methodists? Faithful Lutherans?  Faithful Congregationalists?  
You can ask the same questions about "faithful" Protestants when asking about whether those who are "faithful" in the Novus Ordo Church will be saved.  
Will they be saved?   :scratchchin:  
For obstinate Novus Ordoites and obstinate Protestants, probably not.
But only God knows this.  We must work towards our OWN salvation, with fear and trembling.  Don't fret about Novus Ordoites.  Pray for them, yes, but leave their salvation to God.  

To the extent that they hold and keep the Catholic faith, they can be saved.  If they succuмb to the heresies taught by the Novus Ordo, they will be damned.

It is a fact that there are faithful Catholics who are still trapped in the Novus Ordo.  But they are faithful to the Catholic faith because the true Faith cannot be completely hidden.  They can still read the books of the Catholic Church and still learn the truths of the Catholic Church.  

Emitte Lucem Tuam asked about "faithful Methodists, faithful Lutherans, faithful Congregationalists".  These are in a different situation as they do not seek truth in the pre-Vatican II books and traditions that even Novus Ordo people are aware of and, the faithful ones anyway, pursue, read, and love.

These Protestants are also not likely to be praying the Rosary much either.

By insisting to pretend to be Catholic, the Novus Ordo cannot shut the door on the Catholic faith as the Protestants can.

mikemac

First Vatican Council infallibly teaches: “‘Thou art Peter; and upon this rock I will build My Church,’ these words are proven true by actual results, since in the Apostolic See the Catholic religion has always been preserved untainted...the See of St. Peter always remains unimpaired by any error, according to the divine promise of Our Lord.” And since these “popes” have manifestly taught heresy, promoted ecuмenism and fostered interfaith worship, they clearly cannot be recognized as a successor of St. Peter in the primacy. - See more at: http://www.cmri.org/sedevacantist-position.shtml#sthash.OwuMKU9Q.dpuf

From Who Shall Ascend?:

........the Conciliar Church has undertaken to destroy the cultic aspect of Catholic life. We mean, because the life of the Church is lived and the faith of its people is expressed and exercised in and through the Sacred Liturgy, here has been the main point of attack. Because the Mass and the Sacraments have been corrupted - subjects we shall discuss presently - all supernatural life has been lost. Consequently, there is no salvation within the Conciliar Church. (Intra Ecclesiam Conciliam Nulla Sallus)

.......It is impossible to practice the Faith within the Conciliar Church.

The majority of SVs in the anglo-sphere are gonna say no because they have strong emotional - if not traumatic - experiences with the worst of the worst in the "church of the new advent". There are still good dioceses out there who pray reverently, and, because of the reverence, the parishioners don't really know or care about the doctrinal ambiguities/changes of Vatican II, they just pray and live like their families have for generations, they don't pretend to be experts in everything about canon law/liturgy/theology/culture/politics/running a parish/philosophy/etc. like the modernist and, in some bizarre twist, many traditional Catholics with a keyboard. I should note that these good dioceses are slowly disappearing with increased globalization and digitization.

All that being said, if those NOers are in a state of grace, then yes they will get to heaven. It is much less likely in a place like the USA/Canada/Australia/etc., where parish life will likely kill your faith or the faith of your children (I literally know thousands who've apostatized in Catholic schools). At the same time I know many NO Poles/Filipinos/Tamils who pray the rosary everyday, go to Mass every Sunday and First Friday, observe the First Saturday devotions, wear a brown scapular, etc.

I think the majority of people who doubt the validity of the NO sacraments are having a sensory/emotional reaction. They didn't grow up in NO parishes where everyone took communion on the tongue, and where many even kneeled, and where the priest preached about the four last things, preached about social issues (against sodomite marriage, etc.), where traditional hymns were sung, and where the boy/girl scouts were forced to observe the 12 hours fast and march almost 5k to a 1.5 hour Mass in a forest, etc. etc.

Honestly, if I grew up in one of those American parishes with altar girls, communion in the hand, fag priests, wreckovated churches, and all that other stuff, I'd probably doubt or deny the validity of the NO sacraments. Outside of having horrible/hypocritical parents, there is nothing more psychologically damaging to a child than a bad religion. The worst atheist/liberals I know grew up in the stereotypical Novus Ordo parish. 95% of Novus Ordo parishes have the same effect on people as hypocritical parent(s), the Church teaches one thing (sodomy is bad, etc.) but then you get a fag priest celebrating a secular/effeminate liturgy at your parish. That's asking for trouble.

To sum everything up: I think NO Catholics in valid NO parishes will be saved if they're in a state of grace. The majority of diocese, especially in the anglo-sphere, even if they have validity (doubtful in some cases), serve to kill the faith rather than nurture it, so you will most likely lose the faith attending such places.