I was making a general statement about new Catholic members who ask honest questions. You may have been reading too much into my statement.
There are new and "old" members who do get into robust debates, but, for the record, I do not support ecumenism in any way, shape, form. The Church cannot and should never budge an iota from Her teachings. If a heretic comes to Her (say, through this forum) then we should instruct them in Truth, as He commanded us to do, without compromise.
As to the specifics you noted, Lighthouse, I did see your post in the previous thread and commented accordingly. It is scandalous.