This topic highlights a huge problem with the post VII Church. What do you convert people to, Rome?
My wife and I are former Protestants who did not convert until our late 40s. After much reading and prayer we finally knew that there could only be one true church and that it was the Catholic church. So we started going to Novus Ordo masses and were repelled by what we saw. I had the grace of having attended the Latin Mass as a child with friends and remembered it well. You did not have to understand it to appreciate it's sacred nature, especially compared to the feel-good Methodist church I was raised in.
My wife, a Lutheran, was scandalized also by the lack of reverence in the N.O. Rite, compared to the services she grew up with.
We almost never converted until I contacted an old but somewhat forgotten friend who I knew to be Catholic and who, unbeknownst to me, had gone back to Tradition. I wanted to know if the Catholic Church had split into different denominations like the Methodist religion I grew up in had. (It has!).
My friend worked with us and guided us through the "crisis" in the church and we discovered that there was a traditional Latin Mass chapel close to us. We approached the Priest and asked for instruction and Baptism. That was 15 years ago.
On our own, through grace, prayer and reading we were ready to convert to Catholicism but almost driven away.
So what do you say to potential converts? "Yes, you should become Catholic, but NO you should not go to your local parish church." ?
And now one reads story after story of how that "church" either sends so many signals to potential converts, if not telling them outright that they need not convert and that they are just fine where they are at (we were actually told this several times by Catholic religious and lay people along our journey of conversion much to our consternation).
These Modernists will have to answer for billions of Souls lost that were either driven out, or driven away from the One, True, Faith and Church. They are absolutely A.W.O.L.