That forum is the textbook definition of lukewarm Catholics.
but could you call them Catholics?
I don't think so.
"Cultural Catholics," maybe, but not true Catholics.
So they believe just because it was popular amongst the people they respect and not out of personal experience or true conversion?
I say this is true for all those who have not had trials enough to break them.
I believe there's some of that, but it goes with what I've always called the "My Daddy Was a Democrat Syndrome." You know the type: "Conservative Catholics" who claim they're faithful but vote for Democrats because "My Daddy was a Democrat." In other words, they don't really
believe anything; they just follow the crowd. They have their
own tradition, if you will. Think of all the cars you see on the road with Rosaries hanging from the rear-view mirror. Now, what percentage of those people do you think know
how to even pray the Rosary, let alone actually do it? I bet if you asked most of them why they're a Catholic, you would receive that type of response: "Well, Daddy was a Catholic..." That's a Cultural Catholic to me. They would do well to remember 1 Peter 3:15: "But sanctify the Lord Christ in your hearts, being ready always to satisfy every one that asketh you a reason of that hope which is in you."
EDITED FOR CONTENT