If Mel wants to make another movie about religion, even considering his personal faults, it'll be better than ANY protestant movie could hope to be. I'll watch it in a heartbeat. The first 'passion' movie was excellent. I can't say enough good things about it. I've never watched a movie where you are 'sucked in' in less than 5 minutes. Epic music and acting. Very catholic.
I watched that protestant movie 'Risen' a few years ago. Some parts were very good (mostly the historical/social background), but the lows were very low - the Apostles were characterized as almost effeminate and some of the situations were just so protestant as to make me want to puke.
Jim Caviziel is novus ordo, sure. Does that mean we should burn him at the stake? Doesn't mean that God can't use him to make good movies, or that maybe (just maybe!) he'll convert! Gosh, is that even possible? Based on some of the bitter comments on this thread, i'd think some of you believe conversion doesn't happen anymore.
And i'll pray that Mel would convert by making this new movie. Surely he's had more than his fair share of attacks from the Devil/joos because of his first movie and all the good it produced. If he was as spiritually depraved as some think, he wouldn't care at all about a spiritual movie. All of our spiritual lives are contradictory and complex. As St Paul said in Romans 7: For I do not that good which I will; but the evil which I hate, that I do.