So Tele is WRONG. Jehanne himself broadened the topic beyond keating and then proceeded to discuss some specifics of his own personal finances. What he said didn't add up and he was taken to task some more.
No, if someone wants to discuss the issue then one should discuss the teachings of the Church on the matter. Jehanne was being trolled to discuss his personal situation.
The discussion should be about what the Church teaches on these matters, but instead it was diverted to Jehanne's personal finances.
Incidentally, we know that this issue in particular is problematic for the troll:
Frankly for the last 20 years I've had serious reservations about what has been taken from the Gospels and leveraged and what has been ignored and left out. Christianity seems to have been heavily influenced by the emperor Constatine who as far as I understand it wasn't even a converted Christian until his deathbed.
For example, Jesus seems to make multiple statement that poverty is good and holy and that Christians should seek to have just enough and then give the rest to the poor. Give your coat to a man who needs it and trust in providence.
Hardly any Christians do this however, myself included and the Church has been pretty quiet on the subject for the last 1500 years, and seems to mostly have sided with the Lords and Nobles and Kings, who were little more than the local warlords and mafia strongmen.
(So the Catholic states of Europe were little more than "local warlords and mafia strongmen." Our Catholic history is spat upon by someone pretending the current corruption of our heritage by the ʝʊdɛօ-masonic conspiracy is some "crazy conspiracy theory")
So what happened in the thread?
Instead of discussing the topic from the perspective of Church doctrine (which this person seems to have little faith in), he starts off with a derisive comment about whether or not anyone should agree with Jehanne as Jehanne has little disposable income. That's when the trolling began.
Frankly, you people are willfully blind if you cannot see the malice that is motivating the badgering of Jehanne over the misfortunes that led to his personal situation. It really is very sick and a good Catholic sense should be able to pick that up. Especially if they know this troll's MO.
If you want to take issue with Jehanne's position that's one thing, but that's not what was being done in the thread.