I've been a guitarist for nearly 25 years.
I have RARELY met a guitar player in a "church" setting who could accurately and reverently play accompaniments to hymns, especially on their electric guitars, with all their whang-boxes and fuzz-o-matic thingys and who knows what other contraptions connected.
The FACT is that outside of classical music, any time you have instruments like the guitar present in so-called "worship" music, the LYRICAL content always DEVOLVES and sinks to the populist level of the amateurish strumming of the players.
Banal, sentimental and wishful/emotional lyrical content is ALWAYS married to junior-high-school-garage-band flailing and cacophony.
As I have gotten deeper into the Faith in my theological and devotional understandings, I have grown less and less enamored of playing the guitar. I still play from time to time, but I restrict my playing to the accompaniment of hymns or lyrically-conservative devotional songs.
Also notice that the majority of "worship music" in the post-Vat-II era is as concerned, if not more concerned, with "arrangements" and instrumental passages as it is with the centrality of VOCAL EXPRESSION of the truths of the Faith.
In other words, there are plenty of opportunities to "clap along" and listen to boring instrumental "whomp, whomp, strum strum" nonsense.
90% or better of so-called modern "worship music", which is individualistic, private-interpretation Protestant lyrically, is unsuitable for a capella singing in groups.
As such, it is deficient in its ability to transcend culture and transcend musical fads.
I will be grateful to no end when the return of the Church to Her visible and triumphant glory brings with it a return to the powerful and triumphant musical and lyrical proclamations of the glory of the Triune God in and through His Holy Church.