Send CathInfo's owner Matthew a gift from his Amazon wish list:
https://www.amazon.com/hz/wishlist/ls/25M2B8RERL1UO

Author Topic: Aborting Animals  (Read 2028 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Aborting Animals
« Reply #10 on: April 18, 2013, 05:22:43 PM »
Quote from: Telesphorus
That bull must have been a Charolais.


Most likely!

Aborting Animals
« Reply #11 on: April 18, 2013, 05:57:14 PM »
 :ready-to-eat:


Aborting Animals
« Reply #12 on: April 20, 2013, 10:38:24 AM »
Quote from: TKGS
Sounds as if the new owner of the cattle has a sound reason for what he is doing.  Not only is it not morally wrong, based on the scant information you provide it was probably the only ethical thing to do given the business circuмstances.  The sale of the cows was probably necessary on the part of the seller and the purchase of the cows will ultimately provide the means of life to many people who both buy the meat and to the people who work for him.

The only issue that could have any moral implications here is whether the drugs involved will have any negative impact on the quality and healthiness of the meat produced.

I do, however, understand why, given the moral crassness of society today, the word and the thought of what happened would cause anguish.  My mother used to say that she had an abortion between her 2nd and 3rd child.  She had been a nurse during WWII and what we now call a miscarriage was often called, especially in the medical establishment, an abortion.  Induced abortions, after all, were illegal and considered medically unethical and, frankly, unthinkable.   Medically speaking, at the time, any pregnancy that terminated before birth was called an abortion.  It took me a while, but she finally stopped using the "A-word" because it could be misunderstood.

Unfortunately, though I can explain why, intellectually, it is ok, I can't help you to understand, emotionally, why it is ok.  I will pray for you to understand and accept what was necessary.


Thank you for your reply. I think you are right, but it still makes me sad, ya know? It's ok to be sad about it,I think, while accepting it. I mean, it's dead baby animals. It's something that I am sure I will encounter again at my job, so thank you for praying that I will understand and accept it. God bless you.

Aborting Animals
« Reply #13 on: April 21, 2013, 11:29:34 AM »
Quote from: jen51
Quote from: TKGS
Sounds as if the new owner of the cattle has a sound reason for what he is doing.  Not only is it not morally wrong, based on the scant information you provide it was probably the only ethical thing to do given the business circuмstances.  The sale of the cows was probably necessary on the part of the seller and the purchase of the cows will ultimately provide the means of life to many people who both buy the meat and to the people who work for him.

The only issue that could have any moral implications here is whether the drugs involved will have any negative impact on the quality and healthiness of the meat produced.

I do, however, understand why, given the moral crassness of society today, the word and the thought of what happened would cause anguish.  My mother used to say that she had an abortion between her 2nd and 3rd child.  She had been a nurse during WWII and what we now call a miscarriage was often called, especially in the medical establishment, an abortion.  Induced abortions, after all, were illegal and considered medically unethical and, frankly, unthinkable.   Medically speaking, at the time, any pregnancy that terminated before birth was called an abortion.  It took me a while, but she finally stopped using the "A-word" because it could be misunderstood.

Unfortunately, though I can explain why, intellectually, it is ok, I can't help you to understand, emotionally, why it is ok.  I will pray for you to understand and accept what was necessary.


Thank you for your reply. I think you are right, but it still makes me sad, ya know? It's ok to be sad about it,I think, while accepting it. I mean, it's dead baby animals. It's something that I am sure I will encounter again at my job, so thank you for praying that I will understand and accept it. God bless you.


I don't believe that it is intrinsically wrong when done for a good reason.  Just like I believe that it is acceptable to induce a ewe before her due date if she is down with ketosis and the "removal of the fetal load" is the only way to save her life.  

But is it sickening?  Yes!  I deeply dislike the taking of animal life even though it is often for a good reason.  But it is to give life to us.  When it can be avoided, it should be.  It's fine to raise livestock for meat, to hunt, to use animals in research.  I enjoy a good steak as much as anybody.  We care for them , and in return, they care for us.

God bless you for your concern.  I wish men and women alike would again consider it an honorable thing to care for and protect the weak and defenseless.  It used to be a sign of masculine and feminine strength and not so many feel that way anymore.  We are not called His sheep for nothing!  

Aborting Animals
« Reply #14 on: April 21, 2013, 01:42:55 PM »
Thank you, SOS. I was eagerly anticipating a reply from you, as I'm sure you come across this quite frequently in your field.