InfiniteFaith said: How would you ever prove that Fr. Sudac's "Stigmata" was real or fake?
I am not called upon to determine if someone has the real stigmata, but I am called upon to know the faith, which VII doesn't possess.
First of all, there is a good chance he's not even a priest. The New Rite of Consecration is a fake, so we'd have to find out who ordained him.
Secondly, he would have to be investigated by the Church. Vatican II is not that. So basically he can do what he wants without fear of being checked into, if he is a charlatan.
So I will leave the question alone until the real Church can make a proper investigation. Until then it just doesn't concern me much.