Catholics are going to refer to the statue by any name they feel they like the best.
But Our Lady was quite specific in the name she wanted to use. Evidently, that doesn't matter at all to most here.
Our Lady didn't do the translation. The nuns in Ecuador did. That's the problem. Our Lady did not say "I want Spanish speakers to call me Maria del Buen Suceso de la Purificacion, and I want English speakers to call me Our Lady of Buen Suceso of the Purification." Our Lady didn't say that. And she didn't say to call her Our Lady of the Good Event of the Purification either. You are asking us to take English language lessons from Spanish speaking nuns. That's the problem. When people try to have a discussion about it, they get attacked for backing up TIA or Marian Horvat, despite those names not even being mentioned in our arguments. The funny thing is that before I read this post, I was asking Nuestra Senora del Buen Suceso de la Purificacion to pray for us. The antics of the Suceso crowd have convinced me to do otherwise. Congratulations.
To recap, 'suceso' in Spanish means 1. Thing that happens, especially when of some importance. 2. Success, resultant, completion of an agreement.
'Success' in English can also be used to describe an event. Attached is an example from the 1768 Dictionary of the English Language. We are translating an old text, so I think this is pertinent to the subject. Success: 1. The termination of any affair happy or unhappy.
Milton. 2. Succession.
Spenjer.So given that 'suceso' and 'success' can both mean the same thing in different circuмstances, and that Our Lady never indicated how she wanted to be known by the English speaking world, why would 'success' be unacceptable here, if the speaker understands the sense of the word being used? That is: a thing that happened, of some importance.
Additionally, when you enter into google translate "Maria del Buen Suceso de la Purificacion", it comes out "Mary of the Good Success of the Purification". When you type in "Maria del Buen Suceso", it gives you "Maria of Good Success". And finally, when you type in "Nuestra Señora del Buen Suceso", you get "Our Lady of Good Success".