I don't know about the U.S., but the Novus Ordo "vigils" here in Latin America are a total abomination. I have noticed that in this, in VIGILS, it is one of the things in which they go "overboard" in the Novus Ordo, compared to the regular day to day or Sunday to Sunday "mass". They are always very loud, long, they sing the same songs Protestants sing, also those stupid childish songs with rhetorical questions, and they have drums and loud speakers and the people are all clapping and dancing and "making a mess".
Are they the same in the U.S.?
I can testify to one Novus Ordo parish I observed some number of years ago, for their Saturday evening so-called vigil mass. It was held at Saint Ferdinand's in San Fernando (San Fernando Valley, CA, a.k.a.
"The Valley").
As I have previously explained, the so-called vigil mass in Los Angeles is a Novus Ordo innovation that allows the Sunday liturgy that would be done the following day (Sunday) to be held on Saturday (the day before Sunday), for the convenience of those who would like to do more important things on Sunday and this way they can get their Sunday obligation
"over with" a day early. It comes down to the Church accommodating itself to the world, to meet modern expectations. It also is impressive to the Jєωs, BTW. But I'm sure that's coincidental. (
--Rim shot--)
There is a chicano contingent in the area, and at this liturgy in particular, the front 2 pews were occupied by gang-looking boys and their respective girlfriends with too much makeup. The boys slouched in the pews with their arms in all positions, including lying on top of the pew back to one side or the other or both. The girls squirmed around in between, tossing their hair occasionally.
The music was supplied by a band. They had set up in the left transcept of the sancutary, on a raised platform, and the instruments were a prominent drum set including congos, snare, tenor, bass and high-hat. There were two electric guitars and one electric bass, and a keyboard, which used piano, organ and synthesizer modes. The band played loudly, but not too loud. It wasn't as obnoxious as a "rock concert."
But the part that really got to me was when the priest got into it. Literally. It was during the Offertory that he started to bounce on his toes, and bob his head forward in pace with the thumping of the bass drum. He did this as he walked around one side of the Novus Ordo table/altar, looking like he was going to do a Vaudeville act or something. His little walk was entirely out of place for the beginning of the Offertory, since he was not carrying any burning incense. The chicano boys in the pews really dug it. And that made their girlfriends happy, which I could see because they smiled a lot and stroked the arms of their boyfriends. So I guess one could say this was a "meaningful" experience for them.
But it made me sick, and I had to leave before I saw what the "consecration" looked like.
I certainly didn't want to give myself any nightmares!! At some point later in the week I started to explain this scene to my daughter, who was rather innocent and inexperienced, but I thought she needed to know what the Novus Ordo has in store in some venues. She grumbled at me, asking, "Dad, why are you telling me this?"
.