I know this isn't directed at me but I felt like I had to reply anyway.

" Perhaps alaric is especially bad at English."
Yeah I know the Hispanics in California are especially good at speaking English well am I right?

That must be why there are classes for Spanish speakers.
"comparing Islam, a religion, with what he calls the christian West, a demographic."
The majority of Muslims are Arabs.
" And Catholics would never need learn anything from "infidels"
Damn that Roman Empire full of heretics! Damn those barbarian hordes! Damn the United States! Damn Protestant England! Damn the Chinese! (Need I go on?)

" we have our Blessed Lord Jesus Christ as the infinitely Good and Perfect example."
Yeah still waiting for some "faithful" Christians to step up to the plate. Oh wait Hollywood has been around since the 1920's. So much for that.
"I think its against Catholic spirit to applaud such a despicable people as Mohammedeans,"
You would find to have much more in common with Muslims than with our elites here. Muslims reject ɧoɱosɛҳųαƖ unions, abortion, and premarital sex as immoral while American and European elites celebrate them. And speaking of Muslims the Islamic Empire during the Middle Ages had a greater culture than Christian Europe which was largely illiterate.