Yes, it was.

It was deleted at one point, because I did a search for it. Then somehow it came back from the dead.

Matthew

Vox explained more her actions, saying that because of several threads that Matthew (ChantCd) participated in, that there was quite a bit of flak, and she thought that he knew he was in hot water. I'll try to find out more, since I don't know what recent threads you participated in, Matthew.

Here is what Vox posted as her last post on your thread, Matthew:

ONCE AND FOR ALL: ChantCD's banning had nothing -- that is nada, niente, rien, zilch -- to do with the thread everyone keeps going back to. I did not read the thread and go ban him for it. Get it? Got it? Good! I very clearly stated the reasons for the ban. Those are the reasons.

This thread will not turn into a bash-someone-else thread. It simply will not. Comments about ChantCD would not have been allowed either if he, himself, had not initiated this thread and demanded a public explanation for the ban.

 

Also, by the way, "we" do not bash AQ or Phatmass at the forum; some posters have, and I ask people to lay off (if I see it). I don't see the need for bashing other Catholics myself as it makes enemies for no gain, comes off as bitter and mean, is divisive, and doesn't serve Christ or His Tradition. I'd rather focus mostly on the positive around here and not dwell too long or unnecessarily on what non-trads or trads-with-different-styles than I might be doing. Trad X doesn't like my "style" or doesn't even consider me a trad? Fine. He can do what he wants in his forum, but not in mine. And vice versa. Meanwhile, let's try to be a little kind. So, I am closing and locking this thread. If ChantCD or Carole want to make a rebuttal to anything written above in order to defend themselves, I will post it (mail me). I wish both peace.