Jack Kennedy was charismatic, humorous and all the rest. No argument.
However, Pat Buchanan's latest column deflates the "legend" of JFK's leadership, pointing out that Nixon did a great deal more while also undoing some of the catastrophes of the JFK/LBJ era. (On that, Pat and I will ever disagree. I think Nixon was a big government liberal but Pat is a loyal man.)
Anyway, compared to the post-Reagan era, JFK and RMN both look like fire-breathing Tories. So the point, for all practical purposes, is moot.
JFK's baggage and encuмbrances were monumental. Being a Catholic and being president was something for which neither he nor the government were adequately prepared. While today his "elitist progressivism" would be a natural fit, the average Joe in the early 1960s was much more independent of omnivorous federal predation than today and, especially in the South, the least mention of "change" in the social order really was a war cry. Kennedy's own party obstructed racial legislation long after his death.
As Pat points out, JFK's fall from popularity is now precipitous. His idolaters managed to keep the myth going for 50 years but even that has been too, too much.
The man renounced his obligations to the Faith before Texas Baptists (or whatever sect that gang of mouth-breathers was) to get his Catholicity off the table during the campaign and then went on to give some exciting speeches in office, but not much else.
Was it fun to see him and Jacqueline and the little ones vacationing in Hyannis, to see him stride into the press room and lay waste to the idiotic questions put to him, to see the adoration of the Irish and the Berliners when he visited? Sure! It was terrific!
I think, had he lived on, he was smart enough to have been able to get out of the big holes he dug for himself with the Soviets and to even take a hard look forward, economically, to set some matters right. He DID propose tax cuts and for that he will always remain in the plus column.
The Kennedy mythology, like so much else handed down from Mt. Olympus on the Potomac, is media-generated. Jack was quite a guy with some very serious problems and, quite frankly, was not given the time necessary to work his way upward toward something actually substantial and, thus, worth remembering for important reasons.
http://buchanan.org/blog/nixon-kennedy-myths-reality-6001