I think it's a big mistake for the owners of Forums to push an itinerary. I do think they should strive to develop the best environment for debating truths.
In his sermons at chapels that I and others have heard personally, Bishop Williamson said many times that we don't follow the SSPX, we don't follow Abp. Lefebvre, or any personality, we follow truth. He warned that there may come a day when even the SSPX turns away from truth, and when that happens, we are to follow truth.
As an example: I am a believer in EENS as it is written. Yet, I am always open to discussions on the subject with BODers of every stripe, the more educated they are on the subject the better. It is a pleasure to debate with the learned. This is the mindset that a forum owner should have. anything that they can do to promote this environment is a step in the right direction.
All that said, I once suggested on AQ, that the members should identify themselves as male or female. There is a big difference in the way that women and men analyze things. You can save a lot of wasted writing by knowing the gender of the person. Women generally are feelings oriented, and men generally are cold hard facts oriented. Of course, a few men reason like women, and a few women reason like men.