Does anyone know why so many threads are closed on that forum? And it seems to me since I've been active again on their site, it's always the "controversial" topic's. What is going on?

Pax,
Tarpeian

'Catholic' Answers isn't. Modernist Answers would be a better name.

CA is a commercial enterprise, all the 501(c)3 tosh and piffle aside. They have bills to pay, a $ix figure$ demigod (Karl "Ka-ching!" Keating) to support and a lot o' salaries to doll out.

There's just enough dumb bunnies out in lalaland they can wow into buying their recycled papalotrous/conciliar/TOB/ecuмaniacal/anti-Trad books, lectures, luxury cruises and tapes and CDs to keep 'em going.
 
Thus - they steer clear of controversy in the interests of better living through alchemy ( i.e., changing 1958 years of Church history into conciliar muck. )

You never see the CEO of a Fortune 500 firm speaking his mind on Leno about abortion or gαy marriage or  the Obamanation.

It might hurt sales.

So, don't expect CA to deal directly with a legitimate question like, "Uh, how come all this NO **** looks, sounds and smells like protestant heresy, huh?"

They'd rather deal with somebody else who wants to order autographed boxing gloves right from Jesse Romero and his "The Lord's Gym" program.