If you've ever watched one of their catechetical debates (where the priest's performance was so incompetent one was tempted to think it was intentional) or tried to debate something with the guys who've gone to seminary there you realize they rely heavily on stonewalling and diversion.
What in the world do you mean by this?
Exactly how many ex-seminarians from SSPX seminaries do we have here on Cathinfo besides myself
FYI, Caminus hasn't attended an SSPX seminary.
At any rate, I want to tell you that axe-grinding is not welcome here. I actually spoke to my very neutral SSPX priest about the running of this site. I asked him about SGG and similar debates, etc. and one thing he told me was, "If someone has an axe to grind, tell him to grind it elsewhere." so I really have to follow his advice.
I refer to him as "neutral" as he is unique among SSPX priests. He is a canon lawyer, and used to work in a marriage tribunal in the conciliar Church, before he came to tradition. I would say he is above SSPX politics.
If I see someone grinding an axe on this forum, like you seem to do constantly (against the SSPX), I have no choice but to send you away, by the advice of my confessor.
What is axe-grinding?
Let's put it this way. There is no organization I dislike more than Monsanto (well, maybe Judeo-Masonry) but do you see me interjecting material about Monsanto into each of my posts? No, because I'm not consumed by hatred.
Which leads me to wonder if you are.
Even my post passionate posts -- I post (rant, etc.) and move on. They next day I feel better. Does that *ever* happen with you? Not really. You post about feminism, SSPX "cultishness", disparate-age marriages, sufficient income for marriage, etc. and seem obsessed with topics that touch on human sexuality and marriage.
There is nothing I believe in or discuss which I find necessary to constantly repeat, within topics and posts that have nothing to do with it. You are obsessed about certain topics, and you seem to carry a genuine hatred (anger against a perceived injustice, left to fester) for various parties, including the SSPX. And it shows. This much is not open for debate.
If you want, I can start a poll, "Does Telesphorus show signs of harboring hatred?" and we'll see what everyone thinks. It's not just me, or other "SSPXers". All the CMRI and other sedevacantist members (of which there is no shortage) would be welcome to vote in the poll as well.