Author Topic: Bishop Follows Popes Example: Kneeling Only (Read 2566 times)

Augstine Baker · « **Reply #15 on:** January 02, 2012, 01:20:21 AM »

Quote from: SpiritusSanctus

Quote from: Santo Subito
Reception of Communion in the hand is not intrinsically evil or sacrilegious as it was practiced in the ancient Church, even if it was not the majority practice. If CITH is intrinsically sacrilegious or evil then the Church defected long ago.

Incorrect. CITH was practiced in the very early days of the Church, but even then they used a cloth over their hand when receiving the Eucharist. Eventually, the Church ruled that CITH was evil and should never again be practiced.

People who promote CITH because they insist that it was done of old are misinformed or evil.

You are correct about how the Eucharist was prepared. Actually, it was a lot like preparing the altar, and they never used Eucharistic Monsters either.

It became inpractical, actually to do Communion in the Hand, because it talks too long to cense the hand, purify the hand, place the purificator on the hand... then you have to lick your hands clean when you're done.

Yeah, sounds like the current, Calvinist practice....

There are so many lies like this that are told to support the abuses that go on in the greater part of the Church.... I think I can understand how the Jews murdered God who was sent to save them when I contemplate the kind of disinformation which is spread around.

Alex · « **Reply #16 on:** January 02, 2012, 02:02:21 AM »

Quote from: s2srea

Quote from: Sigismund
So, am I to conclude that being a trad means that even when the pope does something you approve of, you have to find some way to be annoyed by it? Glad to be a lowly semi-trad then...

How about being able to see hypocrisy and not being fooled into thinking every little good thing the pope does is as worthy of praise as you might wish. If his actions were perfectly 'good', then they would be completely supported by other 'good' actions.

This bishop- is he trying his best? I would say yes. Of course we don't know the man, but we know enough to be able to compare him to other liberal and anti-Godly bishops to know this is a positive. He is probably good willed, as people in the NO are not to be thought of as bad. However, you, who has been graced with Tradition, should be able to see where these trads are coming from. They also, are not bad willed.

Trads who seem to harp on, or who are "annoyed by", isolated actions which are good and traditional, don't do it for the sake of being mean and nasty Sigi. They do it trying to see the big picture.

When you go out to buy a car, do you only point out the fact that it drove rather comfortably when you test drove it, or do you look at a Consumers Reports guide to see its reliability? Would you give the same credibility to a Daewoo as you would to a Mercedes?

I think it would benefit trads, the Church, and the world, to do less grumbling and more praying.

Roman Catholic · « **Reply #17 on:** January 02, 2012, 10:24:31 PM »

Modernist means exactly what St. Pius X meant by the term.

And the Modernists today employ the same tactics that they did in St. Pius X's day. Nowadays the Modernists occupy the highest places in the Vatican.

Augstine Baker · « **Reply #18 on:** January 02, 2012, 10:50:49 PM »

Quote from: Roman Catholic

Modernist means exactly what St. Pius X meant by the term.

And the Modernists today employ the same tactics that they did in St. Pius X's day. Nowadays the Modernists occupy the highest places in the Vatican.

You mean it means what you think St. Pius X said it means.

Roman Catholic · « **Reply #19 on:** January 02, 2012, 11:41:32 PM »

Quote from: Augstine Baker

Quote from: Roman Catholic
Modernist means exactly what St. Pius X meant by the term.

And the Modernists today employ the same tactics that they did in St. Pius X's day. Nowadays the Modernists occupy the highest places in the Vatican.

You mean it means what you think St. Pius X said it means.

Please don't act like such a pestiferous twit.

I have read what St Pius X wrote and I know what he meant. He made it clear.