Good posts ggreg, but keep in mind that if two people truly have the blessings of God, lack of money and resources can be turned around for spiritual benefit. Otherwise, the way of the world will sweep them away.
Once you can meet your basic needs I would agree with you. You don't need tons of money. I earn far more than I spend and that is the smart way for anyone to live because that way you are not under pressure and you can take time over life's big decisions. You can also put money aside to help your children go to college and not start adult-life with a ton of debt.
However, realistically, in modern society there are unavoidable costs. Having children costs money. Medical care or insurance costs money. Cars, required to get to mass, cost money. Gasoline to power them costs money. Internet connections cost money. Children require some level of comfort, entertainment, feeding, education. Diapers cost money, running a household costs money. You don't need a foreign holiday every year but if you want your children to take and interest in and be able to engage with the wider world, then a couple of overseas trips (or travelling a few states over in North America) between the ages of 5 and 18 are required to produce rounded characters.
Now sure, you can economize, but
only to a point. Past that point you DO start missing out on opportunities, education and character forming stuff. Stuff that differentiates you as a employment candidate from some wet-back who has just crossed the Rio Grande or hard working Romanian immigrant.
Children have talents. Whether that is playing chess or cross-country running or stage performance. To practice those skills builds their characters and their confidence and practising them costs MONEY.
I know a very poor family who have never taken their children to London. They only live 90mins drive from some of the world's greatest museums and interesting historical sites yet the only time they've seen London is when I drove them. They have a car, but they don't have the money or the inclination to travel there. It's all a bit too much for the parents who live their life like they are in a cloister.
The children are all rather withdrawn and lacking in confidence. Bookish, so to speak. It's difficult to not conclude that being brought up in the boonies (as much as that is possible in the UK), has shaped their personalities or more accurately FAILED to shape them.
That does not bode well for their futures. Who is going to offer them employment when they come across as shy and slightly weird? And how are they going to turn that around in their own life without the upbringing? Once you slip down a social/economic class it is difficult to climb back up.
Unless you marry a girl from a poor background she is highly unlikely to be content to lower her sights THAT much.
My concern is that these are the very people who in 10 years time will find that nobody wants to marry them, because they have very poor job prospects.
My friend got married in his late 40s without a penny to his name. He's ill, so cannot hold down a full time job. He lives on welfare and luckily for him his wife works and does reasonably well with her own cleaning business. But they have one child and live in a small apartment.
Being
realistic about it, Traditionalist Catholics
either have to accept children as God sends them or they have to abstain from sex (which in most circuмstances I would think was a undesirable option which would lead to a bunch of problems), since most normal red-blooded people want to have sex on a reasonably regular basis.
The goal therefore should be to get a job and provide an income that two adults and half a dozen children can live on and pursue some character building pastimes and leisure activities outside of simply saying the Rosary and eating their pottage.
Finally, ask yourself what threads dominate this and other forums. Is Tradland full of wealthy middle class young Trads earning six figure salaries and wondering whether to buy a 5 Series BMW or an E-Class Merc? Not in my experience. Are Traditionalists divorcing because our fathers are spending 80 hours per week starting dot.com companies or globetrotting around the world as senior executives? I think not.
Or - are the threads on this and other forums COMMONLY about young men who find it difficult to find and hold down a decent paying job, or are threatened by Mexican immigrants, complaining about the price of food or debts or think they Joos are to blame for their failure to find anyone to marry by the time they are 30 ?