Send CathInfo's owner Matthew a gift from his Amazon wish list:
https://www.amazon.com/hz/wishlist/ls/25M2B8RERL1UO

Author Topic: Aborting Animals  (Read 2032 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Aborting Animals
« on: April 18, 2013, 10:04:01 AM »
Maybe this is a silly question. Please forgive my ignorance.

I work some hours at a big ranching/farming operation in the office, cooking for hired hands, bookwork, etc. I recieved a package the other day with some medicine in it (I don't rememer the name of the medicine) and I had not heard of it. So I asked the boss's wife what it was. And she told me it was to abort calves. It stunned me. I was not expecting that answer. The thought horrified me. But it's not morally wrong, is it? As in, a sin? My thought would be no, since it is not a human being, but an animal, one in which we have dominion over. After I thought about it more, I thought about hunting and fishing. I have no problem with people killing the animals that way. Maybe it was just the word "abort" that shocked me. One thing that I took mental note of is that when she told me the medicine was to abort the calves, she wouldn't look me in the eye, but istead she said it quickly and quietly while looking down, and switched the subject immedietly. You could tell it bothered her.

What are your thoughts on this? Maybe it's not morally wrong, but ethically wrong? The cows were bred, but the original rancher decided to sell them. My boss bought them, but he doesn't run a cow/calf operation, so to suit his needs he aborted the calves. It just seems careless to me. Not being a very good steward of God's creatures? Maybe I'm being emotional and unreasonable. I know it's a business, but...

Yesterday my boss called the vet for him to come check on those cows who had just aborted their babies. He said there were about 60 fetuses laying on the ground in pasture. It made my stomach turn, and it gave me morbid dreams.

Maybe you can help me straighten my thoughts out. How am I to view this? I feel really bothered by it.

Aborting Animals
« Reply #1 on: April 18, 2013, 10:50:40 AM »
Sounds as if the new owner of the cattle has a sound reason for what he is doing.  Not only is it not morally wrong, based on the scant information you provide it was probably the only ethical thing to do given the business circuмstances.  The sale of the cows was probably necessary on the part of the seller and the purchase of the cows will ultimately provide the means of life to many people who both buy the meat and to the people who work for him.

The only issue that could have any moral implications here is whether the drugs involved will have any negative impact on the quality and healthiness of the meat produced.

I do, however, understand why, given the moral crassness of society today, the word and the thought of what happened would cause anguish.  My mother used to say that she had an abortion between her 2nd and 3rd child.  She had been a nurse during WWII and what we now call a miscarriage was often called, especially in the medical establishment, an abortion.  Induced abortions, after all, were illegal and considered medically unethical and, frankly, unthinkable.   Medically speaking, at the time, any pregnancy that terminated before birth was called an abortion.  It took me a while, but she finally stopped using the "A-word" because it could be misunderstood.

Unfortunately, though I can explain why, intellectually, it is ok, I can't help you to understand, emotionally, why it is ok.  I will pray for you to understand and accept what was necessary.


Aborting Animals
« Reply #2 on: April 18, 2013, 10:55:43 AM »
We should treat animals with respect, and perhaps this treatment of cows is not the best approach.

Aborting Animals
« Reply #3 on: April 18, 2013, 11:11:30 AM »
Is this a procedure that is done in the dairy industry? I am wondering why ranchers would wish to reduce the potential size of their herds.

Aborting Animals
« Reply #4 on: April 18, 2013, 11:27:03 AM »
Quote from: 1st Mansion Tenant
Is this a procedure that is done in the dairy industry? I am wondering why ranchers would wish to reduce the potential size of their herds.


It's a widely used procedure used with almost any time of livestock commodity. Wether ranchers use it is dependent upon what type of operation they are running. These particular cows were intended to be fed out and sent to the slaughter house. After my boss bought them, he then sold them to a customer of ours who paid him to get them fat and sell them. If he was buying the cows to build his herd, he definately wouldn't have wanted to abort them.