Author Topic: Women Running Wild (Read 2051 times)

AspiringToHeaven · « **on:** August 03, 2021, 06:45:43 AM »

Thesis:

In the decadent West, fathers have been deprived of exercising their duty to corporally punish their wives and daughters. Hence we shouldn’t be at all surprised that women are now running wild in every sphere (e.g., destroying nations through their mass entry into politics). Most women in the West are no longer kept in check through the real threat of violence. This is surely a major part of why most women today are so degenerate, full of attitude, and grossly immodest.

Discuss. (Immersed as we all are in modernism, this is now an explosive thesis. I know. Kindly resist any temptation to virtue signal. The capacity to emote is no measure of virtue, especially when such emoting is in conformity with the dismal standards of a thoroughly degenerate age.)

Ladislaus · « **Reply #1 on:** August 03, 2021, 06:53:06 AM »

Sorry, but this is ridiculous. Women were much more virtuous in the past even without corporal punishment. Generally speaking, corporal punishment is effective only for the younger children who have not used the age of reason. After that, they must themselves adopt the proper mindset and attitude. What's happened is ideological, and philosophical, and theological. Even if women were submissive to their fathers and husbands, what exactly would they be submissive to when the men themselves have cast off the "yoke" of religion? If men don't obey God and the Church, then how are women to be expected to obey them? If the men's minds have been poisoned, then the women would be submissive to their evil. It all goes back to the nearly universal loss of faith. To reduce this to the lack of corporal punishment is absurd.

AspiringToHeaven · « **Reply #2 on:** August 03, 2021, 07:44:58 AM »

Quote from: Ladislaus on August 03, 2021, 06:53:06 AM

Women were much more virtuous in the past even without corporal punishment. Generally speaking, corporal punishment is effective only for the younger children who have not used the age of reason. After that, they must themselves adopt the proper mindset and attitude. What's happened is ideological, and philosophical, and theological. Even if women were submissive to their fathers and husbands, what exactly would they be submissive to when the men themselves have cast off the "yoke" of religion? If men don't obey God and the Church, then how are women to be expected to obey them? If the men's minds have been poisoned, then the women would be submissive to their evil. It all goes back to the nearly universal loss of faith. To reduce this to the lack of corporal punishment is absurd.

Your words aren’t without truth. But also not without error. For example:

“Women were much more virtuous in the past even without corporal punishment.”

But the threat of it was always there. This is critical. It was always a real possibility.

“To reduce this to the lack of corporal punishment is absurd.”

Said reduction is no part of the thesis. Notice the word “major” in the last sentence of the thesis, thus conveying that there are other parts involved as well. The thesis hence posits a necessary but insufficient part of the explanation for women running wild today. Your “loss of faith” explanation is definitely another major part of the explanation.

dymphnaw · « **Reply #3 on:** August 03, 2021, 08:41:43 AM »

You seen obsessed with other people's women and with wanting to beat them. I hope you aren't married.

Minnesota · « **Reply #4 on:** August 03, 2021, 08:56:15 AM »

Real men don't beat their wives. Especially if they claim to love them "as Christ loved the Church".

CathInfo.com

Author Topic: Women Running Wild (Read 2051 times)

AspiringToHeaven

Women Running Wild

Ladislaus

Re: Women Running Wild

AspiringToHeaven

Re: Women Running Wild

dymphnaw

Re: Women Running Wild

Minnesota

Re: Women Running Wild