I wouldn't be a "fan" of the theological thought of someone who violates logic in his thinking on such a profound topic as who can be saved and by what means.
I guess that's just me.
Even St Thomas isn't infallible and the Summa contains many errors. Does this mean that seminary students shouldn't study the Summa? The Church declared him a Doctor; does this mean the Church was wrong?

Come on, man. Only God is perfect. Brownson isn't even a saint. But he got A LOT correct on other topics.