Stanley has been banned for his disrespectful outburst against the moderator of the forum. Even his "fellow teammates" on Team Globe Earth haven't had a problem keeping a modicuм of respect for the Moderator, even as the content of their posts contradicts him pretty much 100% of the time. No matter. They manage to control their emotions.
He is so wrapped up in proving the mainstream globe earth "outer space" paradigm, that he lowered himself to the tactic of the Liberals "I'm offended by that -- on behalf of those people" when it doesn't affect you at all.
A comedian was joking about prosthetic legs, and a lady came up to him after the show saying she was offended by that "bit" in his act. He asked if she had a family member with a prosthetic leg. No. He asked a few more questions -- no, she had no reason to be offended. She was just offended FOR them. Then an English guy came up to the comedian, pulled up his pantleg showing his prosthetic leg, and said "That bit about the prosthetics? Bloody brilliant!"
Why would Stanley fall for this obvious error? This behavior that every CathInfo member hates, and we criticize all the time when liberals do it? Because "roscoe" seemed to be coming into the debate on his side. It's a team sport for him. I guess it's not about getting to the truth, having an open mind? It's all "Rah Rah My Team".
Plenty of people on this forum have had issues keeping a "modicuм of respect" for the other posters on this forum,
including you, the moderator. Stanley went off in response to your post to him, which insulted his Catholic faith. I cannot blame him for that at all, considering that many people go off because you won't believe their opinions on a YouTube video where some rando is claiming he's done the math to prove the shape of the earth.
He could have been a lot more charitable, which is part of why I posted above, but the thing is what he was saying was
right and it was in direct response to an insult that you had sent his way first.
As far as him defending roscoe on not having his smoking being aired on the forum... That's not a bad thing for him to want to be careful about. Detraction is a sin that is very hard to make amends for. How do you restore someone's good name? Even if he
was wrong on this point (and I am not totally convinced he was) it seemed that he had reasonably good intentions and was asking a good question. Most people won't question you simply because you are the mod. I know someone who was afraid to reply to you or downvote you because you could just chose to ban them. Pathetic! People on this forum insult each other all the time. You do as well. If you can't take it, don't dish it out. That position would be far more defensible.
He insulted you in defense of his own character, and he spoke the truth. It was rough, but he was truthful.
If you notice his more recent posts, he seems to have been trying to be a lot more civil to people. I believe you are the only recent person to have set him off. Perhaps he has been working on charity and that's why he was concerned about the issue of detraction.
Stanley was a good poster, and very smart. He was one of the more interesting people on the GE side of things, and has contributed some very interesting things to the discussion recently. His banning is a total disappointment in this regard as well. I hope that the FE/GE equation didn't seriously factor into this decision. Somehow I feel that it is part of what caused you to dislike him in the first place.
If I get banned for this, whatever. People can see that I have always tried to be charitable to others. I may not have many posts yet, but that's because I always try to have something quality to contribute. If you chose this as a reason to ban me (she was new and confused) I think people will see the truth. In this case, the truth is what matters. This was a decision motivated by pride, and if it wasn't, then there are several other members who have been equally uncharitable to each other and this sets the goalpost for taking them offline as well. I'm not asking for that mind you. But it is definitely convenient that the only person being banned today is being banned for a tiff with the mod.

Matthew, PLEASE think on this. I am actually praying for you.