Send CathInfo's owner Matthew a gift from his Amazon wish list:
https://www.amazon.com/hz/wishlist/ls/25M2B8RERL1UO

« previous next »
Pages: 1 2 [3]

Author Topic: Is the Remnant Newspaper run by Jews?  (Read 324 times)

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline Pax Vobis

  • Supporter
Re: Is the Remnant Newspaper run by Jews?
« Reply #10 on: Today at 09:42:03 AM »
Mr Matt is a public figure.  He’s allowed to be criticized as such.  Rash-judgement doesn’t apply to such persons.  He has put himself out there as a journalist, a Trad political analyst, an expert insider of sorts, etc.  Rash judgement doesn’t apply to him because we aren’t criticizing HIM (as a person) but we’re criticizing his open, public and ongoing analysis of news. 
Logged

Offline Centroamerica

Re: Is the Remnant Newspaper run by Jews?
« Reply #11 on: Today at 11:04:39 AM »
Quote from: Pax Vobis on Today at 09:42:03 AM

Mr Matt is a public figure.  He’s allowed to be criticized as such.  Rash-judgement doesn’t apply to such persons.  He has put himself out there as a journalist, a Trad political analyst, an expert insider of sorts, etc.  Rash judgement doesn’t apply to him because we aren’t criticizing HIM (as a person) but we’re criticizing his open, public and ongoing analysis of news.
Public figures may be criticized, corrected, and debated. They may not be unjustly presumed guilty, malicious, or morally defective without sufficient evidence.

Therefore the statement that rash judgment “doesn’t apply” is philosophically incoherent. It’s also contrary to Aquinas and inconsistent with Catholic moral theology.


You can make excuses all you want, but the exact words were “he is a shameless grifter”, which is to say that he deliberately deceives people for money and is unashamed of it”.  According to the method of St. Thomas Aquinas, making a public claim like that and doubling down on it without proof is objective mortal sin.

That is then compounded by the name calling and provocations. Under Thomism, those have no power.


(I’m putting Aquinas to every post because in the current crisis, Thomism has criticism for all sides.)

Logged

Offline Jr1991

Re: Is the Remnant Newspaper run by Jews?
« Reply #12 on: Today at 02:54:30 PM »
Look, I’m not claiming with certainty that Matt is controlled by the Jews, but I have noticed a pattern that raises legitimate concerns. On several occasions, I’ve tried to post comments that were only mildly critical of the  Jews, yet they were never approved or published.

I also recall that last year he cleared out the combox, saying that certain commenters were coming over from E. Michael Jones’ site. Given that history and having other members on the site say they have also been banned, I don’t think it’s unreasonable to ask questions about possible infiltration.

Consider what happened with Carrie Prejean and Lila Rose. Last year, Lila Rose interviewed Prejean and was extremely complimentary—at one point even referring to her as “St. Carrie.” However, after Prejean criticized the Jews, Rose quickly threw her under the bus.

Given these patterns, I think it’s fair to raise the question.
Logged

Offline Centroamerica

Re: Is the Remnant Newspaper run by Jews?
« Reply #13 on: Today at 03:59:54 PM »
Quote from: Jr1991 on Today at 02:54:30 PM
Look, I’m not claiming with certainty that Matt is controlled by the Jews, but I have noticed a pattern that raises legitimate concerns. On several occasions, I’ve tried to post comments that were only mildly critical of the  Jews, yet they were never approved or published.

I also recall that last year he cleared out the combox, saying that certain commenters were coming over from E. Michael Jones’ site. Given that history and having other members on the site say they have also been banned, I don’t think it’s unreasonable to ask questions about possible infiltration.

Consider what happened with Carrie Prejean and Lila Rose. Last year, Lila Rose interviewed Prejean and was extremely complimentary—at one point even referring to her as “St. Carrie.” However, after Prejean criticized the Jews, Rose quickly threw her under the bus.

Given these patterns, I think it’s fair to raise the question.



In Thomistic moral theology, suspicion built on personal frustration or incomplete patterns does not justify imputing hidden motives or group control. One may critique public actions, but to speculate about secret influence without proportionate evidence crosses into rash judgment and violates justice and charity. Catholic reasoning demands objective proof, not conjecture drawn from moderation decisions or anecdotal impressions.

Logged

Online josefamenendez

Re: Is the Remnant Newspaper run by Jews?
« Reply #14 on: Today at 04:14:35 PM »
Quote from: Ladislaus on Today at 07:22:50 AM
So ... whatever he does, it'll be "safe" enough with conservative-type Catholics to not alienate too much of his audience.  He did a lot of fence-sitting about Trump leading up to the eleciton.

I wouldn't read criticism of Jews / Zionism as being sufficient proof that someone is not controlled, since there's that roll of gatekeeper.  So, for instance, despite years of claims to "Anti-Semitism", Nick Fuentes has clearly been exposed as a gatekeeper and controlled opposition, and Candace Ownens, IMO, is also a gatekeeper.
personally, I don't think the remnant is DIRECTLY funded by the jews, but I suspect a large part of Matt's conservative Novus Ordo donor base are either zionist Trumpsters or EWTN-style Mother Miriam 'Holy Chosen" types and would be repelled by naming the jew for anything nefarious and call it an "anti-christian" act.- lol

Now Lifesite news was definately a diferent story in the past with pro-zionist articles, stating Catholics couldn't be antisemitic ( whatever that means), but now it seems, since the big shake-up a few months back re: removing JHW, things are progressingwith a much more honest depiction of the JQ and also of Tradition.Better guests , too.
Logged
Pages: 1 2 [3]
« previous next »