Send CathInfo's owner Matthew a gift from his Amazon wish list:
https://www.amazon.com/hz/wishlist/ls/25M2B8RERL1UO

Author Topic: Is Ballet Immoral?  (Read 2418 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline Gray2023

  • Supporter
  • ****
  • Posts: 3573
  • Reputation: +1947/-1000
  • Gender: Female
Re: Is Ballet Immoral?
« Reply #120 on: Yesterday at 01:23:27 PM »
  • Thanks!0
  • No Thanks!0
  • She isn’t trying to find the truth.  And I’m not here to change her.  This site is not “group therapy”.  Sometimes it’s a sermon.  She can either listen to the Truth or ignore it.  I think we all know she won’t listen.  She hasn’t listened to hardly anything, on any topic, since she joined.  I hope she leaves.  She’s a horrible example to younger people on here. 
    I don't think we can really tell a person's intent.  I just think that we can leave out the personal assumptions like "I think we all know she won't listen. She hasn’t listened to hardly anything, on any topic, since she joined.  I hope she leaves.  She’s a horrible example to younger people on here." We don't truly know that.  And many of the regulars who constantly put down people when it is not necessary (is it ever really necessary to say the assumptions we think, out loud?) are also giving people a bad example.

    Plant seeds and be patient.  That is my motto. And also realize none of us know the big picture of God's plan. (I keep trying to tell myself that, otherwise despair comes knocking at my back door.)

    That wasn't much vinegar at me, so thank you. :cowboy:
    Fatti Maschii, Parole Femine

    Offline Pax Vobis

    • Supporter
    • *****
    • Posts: 13241
    • Reputation: +8341/-2575
    • Gender: Male
    Re: Is Ballet Immoral?
    « Reply #121 on: Yesterday at 01:27:03 PM »
  • Thanks!0
  • No Thanks!0
  • I don't think we can really tell a person's intent.  I just think that we can leave out the personal assumptions like "I think we all know she won't listen. She hasn’t listened to hardly anything, on any topic, since she joined.  I hope she leaves.  She’s a horrible example to younger people on here." We don't truly know that.  And many of the regulars who constantly put down people when it is not necessary (is it ever really necessary to say the assumptions we think, out loud?) are also giving people a bad example.

    Plant seeds and be patient.  That is my motto. And also realize none of us know the big picture of God's plan. (I keep trying to tell myself that, otherwise despair comes knocking at my back door.)

    That wasn't much vinegar at me, so thank you. :cowboy:
    When someone consistently acts the same way, you believe them.  Intent has nothing to do with it.  I go based on actions.  And most of her posts are uber-liberal.  


    Offline Seraphina

    • Hero Member
    • *****
    • Posts: 4660
    • Reputation: +3499/-379
    • Gender: Female
    Re: Is Ballet Immoral?
    « Reply #122 on: Yesterday at 03:29:41 PM »
  • Thanks!0
  • No Thanks!0
  • That school sounds wonderfully eccentric and eclectic ❤️🙏You should come to England!! There are ladies like you here…just eloquent and not fitting into the box…you’d love it (am sure you’ve been!).
    Yes, Mrs. Robinnette was definitely eccentric!  I believe she was from France, or at least lived there as a child. My mother referred to her as being a “war bride.”  I didn’t know what that meant and imagined she had fought in the Army in WWII! Yes, I spent about a month in London when I was very young, just age three. There was a park with a beautiful flower garden where Mom and I took walks. I wanted to smell all the different flowers and Mom wouldn’t let me climb over the little fence so I could get an up close sniff of each flower.  

    Offline Gray2023

    • Supporter
    • ****
    • Posts: 3573
    • Reputation: +1947/-1000
    • Gender: Female
    Re: Is Ballet Immoral?
    « Reply #123 on: Yesterday at 03:35:12 PM »
  • Thanks!0
  • No Thanks!0
  • So back to the topic at hand.

    Ballet is defined as "an artistic dance form performed to music using precise and highly formalized set steps and gestures. Classical ballet, which originated in Renaissance Italy and established its present form during the 19th century, is characterized by light, graceful, fluid movements and the use of pointe shoes."

    So by that definition is ballet immoral?

    If you add the costumes, it's use (privately among only women to establish gracefulness or as performance), and the type of people involved, then you have different ideas.

    Here is what AI said about the topic pre vatican 2

    Pre-Vatican II (prior to 1962–1965) Catholic, decency standards were characterized by a strict, authoritative, and traditionalist approach to behavior, modesty, and sacred art
    . The Church emphasized separation from worldly, secular influences and enforced high standards for modesty in dress and conduct, particularly in sacred spaces.
    Key aspects of pre-Vatican II decency included:
    • Modesty and Dress Code: Strict adherence to modesty was expected, often enforced by pastors and sometimes including the wearing of head coverings (veils) for women in church, a practice that has seen a resurgence in some groups.
    • Sacred Art and Decorum: The Church actively regulated art and statues to prevent the display of images that lacked "proper decency and decorum," were of poor artistic quality, or could lead to "dangerous error".
    • Moral and Cultural Separation: The Church generally advocated for separation from modern secular culture, with guidance to avoid "worldly" amusements.
    • Liturgical Reverence: The atmosphere in churches was generally one of silence, passivity, and deep reverence, with a strong focus on the "majesty and inaccessibility" of God.
    • Role of Authority: Decency standards were upheld by a, in some respects, authoritarian structure, where parishioners followed the direction of their priests in matters of faith and morals.
    While some remember this era as a high point of piety, others note that it was a time with hidden, sometimes "authoritarian," pressures. The focus was on compliance with established rules, including abstinence from meat on Fridays and rigorous attendance at Mass.

    Yes, I know AI has a bias that old fashion is bad.


    Just google women's dress effect on men and look at the studies that are out there.  It will be eye opening.

    I had lots of conversations with my husband on this topic and he says it is very hard these days to keep the custody of the eyes, because women don't care.  All of the sɛҳuąƖ harassment training is focused on how a man should speak to a woman, but not on how the dress of a woman distracts the man.  We need to keep all these things in mind.

    If we are truly being the best Catholic, then we should be sacrificial in our love for our neighbor.  It means that us women should care to cover up more, not because the men want us to, but because we are nurturing and we see that it is hard for them, so we do it as a sacrifice because we love God first.


    Fatti Maschii, Parole Femine

    Offline Pax Vobis

    • Supporter
    • *****
    • Posts: 13241
    • Reputation: +8341/-2575
    • Gender: Male
    Re: Is Ballet Immoral?
    « Reply #124 on: Yesterday at 03:43:02 PM »
  • Thanks!1
  • No Thanks!1
  • Women MUST dress modestly or else go to hell.  Yes, charity to men is part of it but….a woman who dresses immodestly is offending God’s law.  Even if no one else is around.  

    You are reducing modesty to merely being a sin against one’s neighbor (ie scandal).  That’s wrong.  Immodesty is wrong before God.  Period.  

    Even if no man is tempted, if no man sins, if a woman dresses immodestly, she has already sinned against God.  


    Offline Gray2023

    • Supporter
    • ****
    • Posts: 3573
    • Reputation: +1947/-1000
    • Gender: Female
    Re: Is Ballet Immoral?
    « Reply #125 on: Yesterday at 03:56:21 PM »
  • Thanks!0
  • No Thanks!1
  • Women MUST dress modestly or else go to hell.  Yes, charity to men is part of it but….a woman who dresses immodestly is offending God’s law.  Even if no one else is around. 

    You are reducing modesty to merely being a sin against one’s neighbor (ie scandal).  That’s wrong.  Immodesty is wrong before God.  Period. 

    Even if no man is tempted, if no man sins, if a woman dresses immodestly, she has already sinned against God. 
    I wasn't trying to reduce anything. You could have added that bit, charitably.  Something simple like "and to add being immoddest is offense a against God and sends you to hell."  I wouldn't have taken offense at that.  I do take offense that you automatically assume that I am trying to do something against God.

    I was trying to reach a women's emotion, which most men have no clue how to do.  If you want to effect change in some women, you can not ignore this.

    Fatti Maschii, Parole Femine

    Offline Pax Vobis

    • Supporter
    • *****
    • Posts: 13241
    • Reputation: +8341/-2575
    • Gender: Male
    Re: Is Ballet Immoral?
    « Reply #126 on: Yesterday at 05:16:03 PM »
  • Thanks!0
  • No Thanks!0
  • I wasn't trying to reduce anything. You could have added that bit, charitably.  Something simple like "and to add being immoddest is offense a against God and sends you to hell."  I wouldn't have taken offense at that.  I do take offense that you automatically assume that I am trying to do something against God.

    I was trying to reach a women's emotion, which most men have no clue how to do.  If you want to effect change in some women, you can not ignore this.
    I have no idea what will or won’t offend you.  It’s not my job to effect change in women, that’s THEIR job - to cooperate with grace.  

    Offline Gray2023

    • Supporter
    • ****
    • Posts: 3573
    • Reputation: +1947/-1000
    • Gender: Female
    Re: Is Ballet Immoral?
    « Reply #127 on: Yesterday at 05:56:44 PM »
  • Thanks!0
  • No Thanks!0
  • I have no idea what will or won’t offend you.  It’s not my job to effect change in women, that’s THEIR job - to cooperate with grace. 
    Isn't everyone's job to cooperate with grace, and doesn't that come from different places (yes I know it comes from God, I just met through different people and all the correct Catholic stuff), and are we suppose to help each other communicate better?

    This society in general spends so much time at each other's throats, trying to look at what is wrong with everything, we don't look for the good that needs to built on.

    I try to, for the most part, reread my posts and see if I was the one receiving how would I react, if it gets a bad reaction, then I adjust accordingly. Sometimes I am successful and sometimes I am not, but I keep trying.  I think we forget that we are all very unique people on the other side of these usernames and that we should try to talk to these people like they are sitting in front of us.

    I am sorry, I digress and I am sorry, I post like this too much.  I just want a better Godly world and that only happens if we try to meet people where they are and help them to the Truth.  Didn't some Saint say that?

    Generated by AI, so it's not perfect but it gives us an idea.

    "St. Francis of Assisi
    is the premier example of a saint who met people where they were, famously embracing lepers, eating with outcasts, and preaching to the poor in their own surroundings. His approach focused on identifying with the marginalized and celebrating God's presence in all creation. 
    Other saints known for this approach include:
    • St. Anthony of Padua: Traveled throughout Italy to preach to people, including heretics, by focusing on the grandeur of the faith rather than harsh condemnation.
    • St. Paul the Apostle: Described in 1 Corinthians 9:19-21, he adapted his approach to engage with both Jews and Gentiles in their own contexts to share the Gospel.
    • St. Francis de Sales: Known as the "Doctor of the Laity," he met people through gentle guidance and focused on holiness in everyday, ordinary life.
    • St. John Vianney: Met the spiritual needs of thousands by spending up to 16 hours a day in the confessional. "

    Fatti Maschii, Parole Femine


    Offline Pax Vobis

    • Supporter
    • *****
    • Posts: 13241
    • Reputation: +8341/-2575
    • Gender: Male
    Re: Is Ballet Immoral?
    « Reply #128 on: Yesterday at 07:14:11 PM »
  • Thanks!0
  • No Thanks!0
  • Isn't everyone's job to cooperate with grace, and doesn't that come from different places (yes I know it comes from God, I just met through different people and all the correct Catholic stuff), and are we suppose to help each other communicate better?

    This society in general spends so much time at each other's throats, trying to look at what is wrong with everything, we don't look for the good that needs to built on.

    I try to, for the most part, reread my posts and see if I was the one receiving how would I react, if it gets a bad reaction, then I adjust accordingly. Sometimes I am successful and sometimes I am not, but I keep trying.  I think we forget that we are all very unique people on the other side of these usernames and that we should try to talk to these people like they are sitting in front of us.

    I am sorry, I digress and I am sorry, I post like this too much.  I just want a better Godly world and that only happens if we try to meet people where they are and help them to the Truth.  Didn't some Saint say that?

    Generated by AI, so it's not perfect but it gives us an idea.

    "St. Francis of Assisi
    is the premier example of a saint who met people where they were, famously embracing lepers, eating with outcasts, and preaching to the poor in their own surroundings. His approach focused on identifying with the marginalized and celebrating God's presence in all creation.
    Other saints known for this approach include:
    • St. Anthony of Padua: Traveled throughout Italy to preach to people, including heretics, by focusing on the grandeur of the faith rather than harsh condemnation.
    • St. Paul the Apostle: Described in 1 Corinthians 9:19-21, he adapted his approach to engage with both Jews and Gentiles in their own contexts to share the Gospel.
    • St. Francis de Sales: Known as the "Doctor of the Laity," he met people through gentle guidance and focused on holiness in everyday, ordinary life.
    • St. John Vianney: Met the spiritual needs of thousands by spending up to 16 hours a day in the confessional. "
    I don’t need to communicate better.  I simply wrote the Truth of moral teaching on immodesty.  You explained it partially; I corrected you.  If you take offense, that’s on you.  Others would not take offense.  

    You’re far too offended on this site.  You really need to take responsibility for being offended, if you decide to keep debating.  Insanity is to keep repeating the same action and expect a different result.  

    Offline Gray2023

    • Supporter
    • ****
    • Posts: 3573
    • Reputation: +1947/-1000
    • Gender: Female
    Re: Is Ballet Immoral?
    « Reply #129 on: Yesterday at 07:53:01 PM »
  • Thanks!0
  • No Thanks!0
  • I don’t need to communicate better.  I simply wrote the Truth of moral teaching on immodesty.  You explained it partially; I corrected you.  If you take offense, that’s on you.  Others would not take offense. 

    You’re far too offended on this site.  You really need to take responsibility for being offended, if you decide to keep debating.  Insanity is to keep repeating the same action and expect a different result. 
    Don't we all need to do things better?  None of us are perfect.  If we are not getting our points understood then we are not communicating well.

    People make many good points on this site, but sometimes they are missed with all the name calling, making things personal, and "you, you, you" stuff.

    Here is what AI says about taking responsibility for being offended

    "Taking responsibility for being offended means recognizing that your emotional reaction is a personal choice based on your interpretations, rather than a direct result of another person’s actions. To take ownership, pause before reacting, analyze why the comment hit a personal trigger, and choose to manage your internal state rather than blaming others."

    I will try to do better, but I expect the same in others.

    Fatti Maschii, Parole Femine

    Offline St Giles

    • Supporter
    • ***
    • Posts: 1775
    • Reputation: +907/-205
    • Gender: Male
    Re: Is Ballet Immoral?
    « Reply #130 on: Yesterday at 07:56:32 PM »
  • Thanks!0
  • No Thanks!0
  • So back to the topic at hand.

    Ballet is defined as "an artistic dance form performed to music using precise and highly formalized set steps and gestures. Classical ballet, which originated in Renaissance Italy and established its present form during the 19th century, is characterized by light, graceful, fluid movements and the use of pointe shoes."

    So by that definition is ballet immoral?

    If you add the costumes, it's use (privately among only women to establish gracefulness or as performance), and the type of people involved, then you have different ideas.

    Here is what AI said about the topic pre vatican 2

    Pre-Vatican II (prior to 1962–1965) Catholic, decency standards were characterized by a strict, authoritative, and traditionalist approach to behavior, modesty, and sacred art
    . The Church emphasized separation from worldly, secular influences and enforced high standards for modesty in dress and conduct, particularly in sacred spaces.
    Key aspects of pre-Vatican II decency included:
    • Modesty and Dress Code: Strict adherence to modesty was expected, often enforced by pastors and sometimes including the wearing of head coverings (veils) for women in church, a practice that has seen a resurgence in some groups.
    • Sacred Art and Decorum: The Church actively regulated art and statues to prevent the display of images that lacked "proper decency and decorum," were of poor artistic quality, or could lead to "dangerous error".
    • Moral and Cultural Separation: The Church generally advocated for separation from modern secular culture, with guidance to avoid "worldly" amusements.
    • Liturgical Reverence: The atmosphere in churches was generally one of silence, passivity, and deep reverence, with a strong focus on the "majesty and inaccessibility" of God.
    • Role of Authority: Decency standards were upheld by a, in some respects, authoritarian structure, where parishioners followed the direction of their priests in matters of faith and morals.
    While some remember this era as a high point of piety, others note that it was a time with hidden, sometimes "authoritarian," pressures. The focus was on compliance with established rules, including abstinence from meat on Fridays and rigorous attendance at Mass.

    Yes, I know AI has a bias that old fashion is bad.


    Just google women's dress effect on men and look at the studies that are out there.  It will be eye opening.

    I had lots of conversations with my husband on this topic and he says it is very hard these days to keep the custody of the eyes, because women don't care.  All of the sɛҳuąƖ harassment training is focused on how a man should speak to a woman, but not on how the dress of a woman distracts the man.  We need to keep all these things in mind.

    If we are truly being the best Catholic, then we should be sacrificial in our love for our neighbor.  It means that us women should care to cover up more, not because the men want us to, but because we are nurturing and we see that it is hard for them, so we do it as a sacrifice because we love God first.
    We don't live in a perfect world, so ballet is at the least imprudent.

    I think I managed to strike what little is left of this dead horse.:laugh1:
    "Be you therefore perfect, as also your heavenly Father is perfect."
    "Seek first the kingdom of Heaven..."
    "Every idle word that men shall speak, they shall render an account for it in the day of judgment"


    Offline Seraphina

    • Hero Member
    • *****
    • Posts: 4660
    • Reputation: +3499/-379
    • Gender: Female
    Re: Is Ballet Immoral?
    « Reply #131 on: Yesterday at 09:19:35 PM »
  • Thanks!0
  • No Thanks!0
  • In all honesty, I’m not much interested in ballet. Other than learning the basics as a very young girl in an all girls’ class and a couple of “performances” for our parents, mostly Moms, that’s it. We certainly didn’t perform immodest moves or wear immodest clothes. The only professional ballet performance I’ve ever seen is The Nutcracker Suite at Lincoln Center in NYC in 1972. 
    Our seats were so far up that if anything was immodest, I didn’t notice. 

    Offline FarmerWife

    • Supporter
    • ***
    • Posts: 658
    • Reputation: +424/-46
    • Gender: Female
    Re: Is Ballet Immoral?
    « Reply #132 on: Yesterday at 10:06:12 PM »
  • Thanks!0
  • No Thanks!0
  • What did young men and women do to meet in the past instead of dance?
    They just talk to each other, have meaningful conversations about whatever. How else are you going to vet for marriage? The only dancing you should be doing is with your wife/husband.