Author Topic: Fr. Roncalli, suspect of Modernism (Read 518 times)

Geremia · « **on:** December 07, 2013, 03:24:13 PM »

Here's some verification of 's claims:

• There was a "Roncalli file" with evidence making him suspect of heresy. It was a 30 year dossier with the caption "under suspicion of Modernism."

• He was friends with the Italian Modernist and socialist Ernesto Buonaiuti.

• He had socialist and worker-priest sympathies.

• He read Duchesne's History of the Early Church, which was condemned for being Modernist, and feared he would be defrocked by Card. De Lai, who reprimanded him in a chilling letter. He did not heed Card. De Lai.

Neil Obstat · « **Reply #1 on:** December 09, 2013, 01:37:39 AM »

.

Your thread title should read, "...suspected...," not '...suspect...'.

When you say, "Roncalli, suspect of Modernism," it literally would mean that Modernism suspected Roncalli of something, but just what it was, of which Roncalli was suspected, isn't mentioned.

"Under suspicion of" is synonymous with "suspected of."

"Suspect of" is synonymous with "suspected by," (to be followed with the name of the person or entity that was suspicious of someone or something else).

Roncalli, suspected of Modernism.

Here is the video you linked:

[youtube]https://www.youtube.com/embed/hD0PE1YlHNQ[/youtube]

.

Author Topic: Fr. Roncalli, suspect of Modernism (Read 518 times)

Geremia

Fr. Roncalli, suspect of Modernism

Neil Obstat

Fr. Roncalli, suspect of Modernism