Catholic Info

Traditional Catholic Faith => Fighting Errors in the Modern World => Topic started by: Tradplorable on October 10, 2017, 03:46:50 PM

Title: Elvis is BACK!
Post by: Tradplorable on October 10, 2017, 03:46:50 PM
In honor of my new avatar, which commemorates the creation of the ghetto, I thought I'd share this with you all:
.
.

Elvis is ALIVE! 
.
He didn't die, he's back!

.
.
He's an American hero who fought the mafia, drugs, and chased down America's enemies in Weather Underground terrorists William Ayers and Bernadine Dohrn.
.
This is an amazing story and rumor has it he will be revealng himself on his 83rd birthday on January 8th.


.

.
Watch the film here, Elvis Found Alive, by filmmaker Joel Gilbert, who made an expose film about President Obama called Dreams From My Real Father:
.
.
http://main.snagfilms.com/films/title/elvis_found_alive.
.
Title: Re: Elvis is BACK!
Post by: Tradplorable on October 10, 2017, 04:01:58 PM
Here's the accompanying album he recorded in late 2011, released in January 2012:

.
https://lindahoodsigmontruth.com/jesses-album-of-songs-released-on-the-cd-elvis-found-alive-in-2012/

I like the song he wrote for his daughter, Lisa Marie, and his cover of Garth Brooks' "The Dance."
.
.
And his cover of Michael Jackson's "Wanna Be Startin' Somethin" is quintessential Elvis:
.
.
https://lindahoodsigmontruth.com/jesses-album-of-songs-released-on-the-cd-elvis-found-alive-in-2012/
Title: Re: Elvis is BACK!
Post by: St Ignatius on October 10, 2017, 06:17:50 PM

Why do you think he's so important as to be your avatar?

Loose screw....?

(http://4.bp.blogspot.com/-d5EuZ6pT5Os/TZMURMi6uII/AAAAAAAAAKc/qGcHzqNtBQw/s1600/Screw-loose.lowrez.jpg)
Title: Re: Elvis is BACK!
Post by: 1st Mansion Tenant on October 10, 2017, 06:28:32 PM
Yet when I predicted that encouraging this junk would lead to Bigfoot sightings, I was chastened.  ::)
Title: Re: Elvis is BACK!
Post by: Neil Obstat on October 10, 2017, 06:47:45 PM

This is all relevant. Elvis is not dead, the Earth is flat. I will say there are a lot of conspiaracies out there and I believe a lot of them, but this guy will believe anything. The fact that Elvis, a theosophist etc..., is his hero or whatever, is very revealing.

.
After Elvis died, the demon who possessed him wandered about looking for someone else to possess. 
.
Looks like he found someone, maybe brought along 7 more demons more wicked than himself.
.
Title: Re: Elvis is BACK!
Post by: Neil Obstat on October 10, 2017, 06:48:59 PM
Yet when I predicted that encouraging this junk would lead to Bigfoot sightings, I was chastened.  ::)
.
Not to worry anymore -- you're safe now! You are among friends.
.
Title: Re: Elvis is BACK!
Post by: Tradplorable on October 10, 2017, 06:57:46 PM

 Why do you think he's so important as to be your avatar?
It was a JOKE. We were sent to the ghetto, and so I thought of his song, which I posted.
.
.
You guys need to get a grip...and a sense of humor.
.
Title: Re: Elvis is BACK!
Post by: Neil Obstat on October 10, 2017, 06:59:36 PM
Loose screw....?

(http://4.bp.blogspot.com/-d5EuZ6pT5Os/TZMURMi6uII/AAAAAAAAAKc/qGcHzqNtBQw/s1600/Screw-loose.lowrez.jpg)
.
He might like to use the new Jello brain mold................
.
(https://s14-eu5.ixquick.com/cgi-bin/serveimage?url=http%3A%2F%2Fmylitter.com%2Fwp-content%2Fuploads%2F2011%2F09%2Fhalloween-brain-food.jpg&sp=d2b7254f528bde92c5495ffb63482b4e)

Quote
You guys need to get a grip...and a sense of humor.

(https://s14-eu5.ixquick.com/cgi-bin/serveimage?url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.instructables.com%2Ffiles%2Fderiv%2FFLE%2FOI6I%2FGPLJ1AWE%2FFLEOI6IGPLJ1AWE.MEDIUM.jpg&sp=d440fe584e569696da4ae15593588c5c)
This one is wired with electrodes for EEG-like presentations!
.
(Electroencephalography for flat-earthers who deny satellites exist)
.
Title: Re: Elvis is BACK!
Post by: Tradplorable on October 10, 2017, 07:01:56 PM

Got this off of a Baptist site. There are many other sites with this type of information. Why do you think he's so important as to be your avatar?
I don't really know much about Elvis Presley's personal beliefs. I am aware that present-era musicians are deeply involved in the occult, but I don't know about Presley's involvement.
.
.
I do know there were a lot of anomalies around his death, and many sightings over the years. It wouldn't surprise me if he faked his death at all. It must have been a crushing level of fame.
.
.
If it's really him in the film, and he shows up next year, it sounds like he was certainly a patriot that loved his country.
.
Title: Re: Elvis is BACK!
Post by: Neil Obstat on October 10, 2017, 07:27:45 PM
                       It was a JOKE.                     We were sent to the ghetto...
.
.
You guys need to get a grip...and a sense of humor.
.
.
It was just a JOKE all along?! ............................ So you've been SAYING "the earth is flat" but you don't really mean it?!
.
WOW that's hilarious.       :laugh1:      :laugh2:      :laugh1:      :laugh2:      :laugh1:
.
Title: Re: Elvis is BACK!
Post by: Tradplorable on October 11, 2017, 08:16:25 AM
.
It was just a JOKE all along?! ............................ So you've been SAYING "the earth is flat" but you don't really mean it?!
.
WOW that's hilarious.       :laugh1:      :laugh2:      :laugh1:      :laugh2:      :laugh1:
.
No, Neil Stupidat, the flat earth is not a joke. However, my avatar is. Try to keep up.
Title: Re: Elvis is BACK!
Post by: DZ PLEASE on October 11, 2017, 09:17:51 AM
Try to keep up.
Now that's funny.
Title: Re: Elvis is BACK!
Post by: DZ PLEASE on October 11, 2017, 09:24:53 AM
But not funny ha-ha
Mmm... I'm going more with a kinda "derisive incredulity" motif on this one.
Title: Re: Elvis is BACK!
Post by: cassini on October 13, 2017, 12:46:55 PM

Unfortunately the video is gone Tradplorable. I got through up to the interview and said I would finish it today. Alas its gone. I was so much looking forward to it.

It was of course a skit, a great bit of fiction enacted as real. I enjoyed the visit to Elvis's house to see his gold records and pictures, looking at his shows that brought fun to us teenagers.

I have just watched the video on Elvis and his twinless twins. Fascinating, especially the X-ray of the two twins in the womb. I heard one man state life begins at conception. I was moved by the loss suffered by the twin that lived/lives. I could picture God creating two souls at the same time inside the womb of the mother. I can understand how such lliving twins could feel a spititual communication with their dead brother or sister. I could also understand the feeling of guilt that they lived and their twin died. If Elvis was tormented by this, God will have understood.

Elvis played a huge part in my life and others of my generation. I do not recall his giving any scandal to me or other Catholic friends in our time. Indeed I always associated him with Christianity which is more that can be said about any of today's stars. We loved his rock and roll, often played at the parish dances we went to in the early 60s. These dances always had a priest there to separate any boy and girl getting too close to one another. 

Recently there was a great programme on Elvis's demise and death. there were interviews with some of his friends and musicians who played with him, some who found him dead and accompanied him to the hospital. Elvis is dead, Lord have mercy on his soul.

Once again I am shocked at the judgements posted on this forum. Elvis was a devil and all that.
I am the same age Elvis would have been, so lived every day he lived and was never scandalised by him. Didn't the Lord himself tell us not to judge lest we shall be judged.

Finally I recall another comment on Elvis. It went like this:

‘The numerological decline of practicing Christians in the world would appear to be irreversible. The present Pope [John Paul II] has said that if the decline continues at the present rate then in 70 years there will be no Christians on the face of the planet [see, always “planet” not the Earth]. This prophecy is perhaps pessimistic. It ignores the human capacity to be inconsistent…Christianity will survive in a more or less undiluted form. A civilisation which readily believes in flying saucers and the resurrection of Elvis Presley should have no difficulty to swallow what is dished out by the tele-evangelists.’ ---A. N. Wilson, writer and historian, Daily Express, Oct. 21, 1999, pp.44-45.

Oh, just about to watch a recorded investigation into the 'Big Foots of the world, should be interesting.
Title: Re: Elvis is BACK!
Post by: Meg on October 13, 2017, 01:15:35 PM

I think that Elvis basically started out as a nice old-fashioned young man, but he got caught up in the nasty music industry, which is evil. His dancing onstage was very, well, immodest to say the least. 

Still, I remember reading the autobiography of the actress Dolores Hart, who eventually became a nun, and how Elvis asked her on a date when they were making a film together. She declined his offer, but she wrote that he was always such as gentleman, and he called her "Miss Dolores." 

I always thought it was sad that the media treated him so horribly when he was older and overweight. And also sad that his wife left him when times got tough. 



Title: Re: Elvis is BACK!
Post by: Meg on October 13, 2017, 01:32:16 PM

There have been some good tribute songs about Elvis, but my favorite is the one by bluegrass singer Gillian Welch, called, I think, "I was thinking that night about Elvis." I would post a video of the song, but unfortunately the song has immodest elements (which I don't think was necessary), but it also has some good observations about Elvis. And the melody is wonderfully bluegrass. 
Title: Re: Elvis is BACK!
Post by: Clemens Maria on October 13, 2017, 02:18:46 PM
There is no question that Elvis was a very flawed individual.  He is certainly not a model for Catholics.  That being said, there were signs of a possible conversion.  He was a long-time friend of Fr. Bolduc.  They met in the US Army in Germany.  They were room-mates.  After the Army they kept in touch and Elvis donated money to Fr. Bolduc's apostolates.  Elvis was certainly aware that Fr. Bolduc was not only a Catholic priest but also a traditional Catholic priest.  Elvis also recorded a song in honor of Our Lady.

Elvis Hail Mary (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XGlelYprF2M)
Title: Re: Elvis is BACK!
Post by: Tradplorable on October 13, 2017, 02:44:53 PM
Unfortunately the video is gone Tradplorable. I got through up to the interview and said I would finish it today. Alas its gone. I was so much looking forward to it.

It was of course a skit, a great bit of fiction enacted as real. I enjoyed the visit to Elvis's house to see his gold records and pictures, looking at his shows that brought fun to us teenagers.

I have just watched the video on Elvis and his twinless twins. Fascinating, especially the X-ray of the two twins in the womb. I heard one man state life begins at conception. I was moved by the loss suffered by the twin that lived/lives. I could picture God creating two souls at the same time inside the womb of the mother. I can understand how such lliving twins could feel a spititual communication with their dead brother or sister. I could also understand the feeling of guilt that they lived and their twin died. If Elvis was tormented by this, God will have understood.

Elvis played a huge part in my life and others of my generation. I do not recall his giving any scandal to me or other Catholic friends in our time. Indeed I always associated him with Christianity which is more that can be said about any of today's stars. We loved his rock and roll, often played at the parish dances we went to in the early 60s. These dances always had a priest there to separate any boy and girl getting too close to one another.

Recently there was a great programme on Elvis's demise and death. there were interviews with some of his friends and musicians who played with him, some who found him dead and accompanied him to the hospital. Elvis is dead, Lord have mercy on his soul.

Once again I am shocked at the judgements posted on this forum. Elvis was a devil and all that.
I am the same age Elvis would have been, so lived every day he lived and was never scandalised by him. Didn't the Lord himself tell us not to judge lest we shall be judged.

Finally I recall another comment on Elvis. It went like this:

‘The numerological decline of practicing Christians in the world would appear to be irreversible. The present Pope [John Paul II] has said that if the decline continues at the present rate then in 70 years there will be no Christians on the face of the planet [see, always “planet” not the Earth]. This prophecy is perhaps pessimistic. It ignores the human capacity to be inconsistent…Christianity will survive in a more or less undiluted form. A civilisation which readily believes in flying saucers and the resurrection of Elvis Presley should have no difficulty to swallow what is dished out by the tele-evangelists.’ ---A. N. Wilson, writer and historian, Daily Express, Oct. 21, 1999, pp.44-45.

Oh, just about to watch a recorded investigation into the 'Big Foots of the world, should be interesting.
It's still there cassini:
http://main.snagfilms.com/films/title/elvis_found_alive
.
.
Title: Re: Elvis is BACK!
Post by: cassini on October 14, 2017, 06:14:44 AM
There is no question that Elvis was a very flawed individual.  He is certainly not a model for Catholics.  That being said, there were signs of a possible conversion.  He was a long-time friend of Fr. Bolduc.  They met in the US Army in Germany.  They were room-mates.  After the Army they kept in touch and Elvis donated money to Fr. Bolduc's apostolates.  Elvis was certainly aware that Fr. Bolduc was not only a Catholic priest but also a traditional Catholic priest.  Elvis also recorded a song in honor of Our Lady.

Elvis Hail Mary (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XGlelYprF2M)

Absolutely beautiful Clemens, many thanks.
Title: Re: Elvis is BACK!
Post by: cassini on October 14, 2017, 06:27:54 AM
It's still there cassini:
http://main.snagfilms.com/films/title/elvis_found_alive
.
.

Got it tradplorable, thanks, I am in to it one hour. Gosh I need a break. 

What a fascinating story of Elvis's life. The history of his time, and America, is most interesting. Certainly no saint, but what a complicated life he had, good guy, bad guy. But then came the Beatles, drugs, hippies etc. 

I lived through it all. Never had any time for the Beatles, hated their music. Moreover you could not dance to it.

Gee, its like going back into the past.
Title: Re: Elvis is BACK!
Post by: Tradplorable on October 14, 2017, 05:16:37 PM
Got it tradplorable, thanks, I am in to it one hour. Gosh I need a break.

What a fascinating story of Elvis's life. The history of his time, and America, is most interesting. Certainly no saint, but what a complicated life he had, good guy, bad guy. But then came the Beatles, drugs, hippies etc.

I lived through it all. Never had any time for the Beatles, hated their music. Moreover you could not dance to it.

Gee, its like going back into the past.
Same here, was never into the Beatles. I hope it turns out to be true. Wouldn't that be something if he does reappear? People will go crazy! 
Title: Re: Elvis is BACK!
Post by: Nadir on October 14, 2017, 06:16:44 PM
Same here, was never into the Beatles. I hope it turns out to be true. Wouldn't that be something if he does reappear? People will go crazy!
I don't understand who you could wish him to be alive in this mess of a world With people going crazy. 
Thank you, Cassini, for a note of common sense and to ClemensMaria for the Hail Mary by Elvis, who sings that Mary is holding back her Son's hand.
Makes me think that at worst Elvis is suffering in purgatory, so pray for him.
Title: Re: Elvis is BACK!
Post by: DZ PLEASE on October 15, 2017, 07:40:01 AM
Does this mean that you think "at best" Elvis went directly to heaven at his death? Or do you think "at best" he's still alive?
Guess Hell is only for Catholics...

Title: Re: Elvis is BACK!
Post by: DZ PLEASE on October 15, 2017, 03:00:25 PM
(retracted as unnecessary.)
Title: Re: Elvis is BACK!
Post by: DZ PLEASE on October 15, 2017, 03:01:35 PM
I could be wrong, if so, I apologize but it seemed to follow my comment?
  Not needed, I have an extra tee-shirt if you like. :jester:
Title: Re: Elvis is BACK!
Post by: DZ PLEASE on October 15, 2017, 03:05:19 PM
Freedom, his statement didn't have anything to do with you from what I saw. It was in reference to Nadir's comment I believe.
  :cheers:
Title: Re: Elvis is BACK!
Post by: cassini on October 15, 2017, 04:28:09 PM
Yet when I predicted that encouraging this junk would lead to Bigfoot sightings, I was chastened.  ::)

Finished watching very good program on Bigfoot 1st Mansion. It showed the number of sightings world-wide. In America there was the most, many hundreds. The famous video of one was they found a hoax. Others were also admitted to be a hoax. One guy who saw one went back the next day and found hairs. They did DNA tests and found it was a deer's hair. Others were bears.

The footprints were duplicated by a test with a bear, one front paw was stood on by the leg paw giving a huge human type footprint so no evidence with them.

The experts concluded that a Human-Ape type Bigfoot just does not exist, just like a live Elvis as I think you meant.
Title: Re: Elvis is BACK!
Post by: OHCA on October 15, 2017, 10:17:31 PM
Unfortunately the video is gone Tradplorable. I got through up to the interview and said I would finish it today. Alas its gone. I was so much looking forward to it.

It was of course a skit, a great bit of fiction enacted as real. I enjoyed the visit to Elvis's house to see his gold records and pictures, looking at his shows that brought fun to us teenagers.

I have just watched the video on Elvis and his twinless twins. Fascinating, especially the X-ray of the two twins in the womb. I heard one man state life begins at conception. I was moved by the loss suffered by the twin that lived/lives. I could picture God creating two souls at the same time inside the womb of the mother. I can understand how such lliving twins could feel a spititual communication with their dead brother or sister. I could also understand the feeling of guilt that they lived and their twin died. If Elvis was tormented by this, God will have understood.

Elvis played a huge part in my life and others of my generation. I do not recall his giving any scandal to me or other Catholic friends in our time. Indeed I always associated him with Christianity which is more that can be said about any of today's stars. We loved his rock and roll, often played at the parish dances we went to in the early 60s. These dances always had a priest there to separate any boy and girl getting too close to one another.

Recently there was a great programme on Elvis's demise and death. there were interviews with some of his friends and musicians who played with him, some who found him dead and accompanied him to the hospital. Elvis is dead, Lord have mercy on his soul.

Once again I am shocked at the judgements posted on this forum. Elvis was a devil and all that.
I am the same age Elvis would have been, so lived every day he lived and was never scandalised by him. Didn't the Lord himself tell us not to judge lest we shall be judged.

Finally I recall another comment on Elvis. It went like this:

‘The numerological decline of practicing Christians in the world would appear to be irreversible. The present Pope [John Paul II] has said that if the decline continues at the present rate then in 70 years there will be no Christians on the face of the planet [see, always “planet” not the Earth]. This prophecy is perhaps pessimistic. It ignores the human capacity to be inconsistent…Christianity will survive in a more or less undiluted form. A civilisation which readily believes in flying saucers and the resurrection of Elvis Presley should have no difficulty to swallow what is dished out by the tele-evangelists.’ ---A. N. Wilson, writer and historian, Daily Express, Oct. 21, 1999, pp.44-45.

Oh, just about to watch a recorded investigation into the 'Big Foots of the world, should be interesting.
Nothing scandalous?  Why wouldn't early programming televise him below the waist in his performances?
Title: Re: Elvis is BACK!
Post by: Nadir on October 16, 2017, 01:25:05 AM
Does this mean that you think "at best" Elvis went directly to heaven at his death? Or do you think "at best" he's still alive?
No, and no.
Title: Re: Elvis is BACK!
Post by: DZ PLEASE on October 16, 2017, 04:14:59 AM
Nothing scandalous?
Grant that this is true; so what?
Title: Re: Elvis is BACK!
Post by: cassini on October 16, 2017, 08:53:09 AM
Nothing scandalous? Why wouldn't early programming televise him below the waist in his performances?

We are talking about the early 1960s here, and what I said was that Elvis never scandalised me or others, boys and girls, of my place and generation. Maybe we were all so innocent then but I never remember anybody interpreting his dancing as anything other than great fun. Thank God for that innocence, it kept our minds clean. Maybe others, like TV, did interpret his dancing as vulgar and it took time to come to terms with it.

Later, when the music business was corrupted with the Beatles, Rolling stones and others who lived with drugs and promiscuity it tainted the rock and roll of Elvis's time. 

Elvis said he just moved to the music, just as we rock and rolled to the music, just as Irish dancers move to the music.

https://www.rte.ie/entertainment/2017/1013/912283-alex-collins-baltimore-ravens-irish-dancing/

Finally, I understand Elvis was a good friend of Fr Bolduc, a onetime superior of the American SSPX. He asked Elvis to help the SSPX district headquarters. Elvis gave them a large donation.  
Title: Re: Elvis is BACK!
Post by: DZ PLEASE on October 16, 2017, 09:20:08 AM
If you believe he is in purgatory, the prayers need be directed towards you. The servant of Satan died face down with his pajamas around his ankles. Some claim he was reading a pornography book, which I would presume to believe since he was addicted to fornication.
Certainly didn't die in the odor of sanctity.
Quote
"To the Unknown God"

Once more, before I move on
 I am directing my gaze forward
 In loneliness, I am lifting my hands
 Up to Thee, to whom I flee,
 To whom I, from the deepest bottom of my heart
 Solemnly consecrate altars
 So that, at all times,
 His voice would call me again.
Thereupon, written deeply inside, the word
 Is blazing like fire: To the unknown God:
 I am his, even if I remained with the hord of the infidels
 Up to this hour:
 I am his – and I feel the ties
 That pull me down in fight
 And, even if I should flee,
 Still would force me into his service.
I want to know Thee, Unknown One
 Thou, who is reaching deeply into my soul,
 Who is raging through my life like a storm
 Thou Unfathomable One, akin to me!
I want to know Thee, and serve Thee.

Friedrich Nietzsche
Title: Re: Elvis is BACK!
Post by: Tradplorable on October 16, 2017, 10:13:56 AM

Finally, I understand Elvis was a good friend of Fr Bolduc, a onetime superior of the American SSPX. He asked Elvis to help the SSPX district headquarters. Elvis gave them a large donation.  
Interesting. Thanks for sharing.
Title: Re: Elvis is BACK!
Post by: Meg on October 16, 2017, 10:47:01 AM
We are talking about the early 1960s here, and what I said was that Elvis never scandalised me or others, boys and girls, of my place and generation. Maybe we were all so innocent then but I never remember anybody interpreting his dancing as anything other than great fun. Thank God for that innocence, it kept our minds clean. Maybe others, like TV, did interpret his dancing as vulgar and it took time to come to terms with it.

Later, when the music business was corrupted with the Beatles, Rolling stones and others who lived with drugs and promiscuity it tainted the rock and roll of Elvis's time.

Elvis said he just moved to the music, just as we rock and rolled to the music, just as Irish dancers move to the music.

https://www.rte.ie/entertainment/2017/1013/912283-alex-collins-baltimore-ravens-irish-dancing/

Finally, I understand Elvis was a good friend of Fr Bolduc, a onetime superior of the American SSPX. He asked Elvis to help the SSPX district headquarters. Elvis gave them a large donation.  

I agree. I think it best to have a charitable view of Elvis, rather than condemn him, though that might be the minority view here. But then I do believe in BoD.  ;D

I like the video of the NFL football player (big black guy) who loves Irish dancing. Moving to music isn't necessarily sinful. Even Blessed Jacinta (of Fatima) loved to dance. But of course she eventually gave it up. 

I think it's good to remind everyone that there was never any scandal regarding Elvis when you were young in the 1960's. 

That Elvis gave a large donation to the SSPX shows that he at least had great respect for Fr. Bolduc, and he was not adverse to Traditional Catholicism, unlike like most Protestants (and Novus Ordo Catholics).
Title: Re: Elvis is BACK!
Post by: DZ PLEASE on October 16, 2017, 10:57:53 AM
It's this level of rigor that really inspires...
Title: Re: Elvis is BACK!
Post by: Meg on October 16, 2017, 11:00:18 AM
It's this level of rigor that really inspires...

Are you only inspired by rigor, Dizzy?
Title: Re: Elvis is BACK!
Post by: DZ PLEASE on October 16, 2017, 11:05:06 AM
It's this level of rigor...
Title: Re: Elvis is BACK!
Post by: Meg on October 16, 2017, 11:30:17 AM
Meg, here is why you and many many others have been hoodwinked these days...you and many others judge a large donation (allegedly) as good or an indication that he was a good person.... and look past the fact that the man was an adulterer among many other things and lived in constant enmity with God.

This is a common theme these days..."Oh he/she was such a good person, would give you the shirt off their back, etc... all at the same time lived publicly as a fornicator, adulterer, etc... hater of God and His commands. Any good a person does is of no value if they are not in a state of grace when they preform it.

...merely naturally good acts are only a counterfeit of virtue since they are neither permanent nor sufficient for salvation.
St. Pius X  Editae Saepe

Well, yes, you may be correct, GJC. I'll concede that. Given that I lived quite a sinful life when I was young, but have since turned around, I have a difficult time condemning others. I'm old now, but my sin is always before me. 

I do understand what you're saying.
Title: Re: Elvis is BACK!
Post by: DZ PLEASE on October 16, 2017, 11:33:09 AM
... I have a difficult time condemning others.
:laugh2:
Title: Re: Elvis is BACK!
Post by: Meg on October 16, 2017, 11:34:39 AM
:laugh2:

Have you yourself led a sinless life, Dizzy? 
Title: Re: Elvis is BACK!
Post by: Carissima on October 16, 2017, 11:55:42 AM
:laugh2:
There is an ocean of difference between condemning someone of their past sins and correcting someones current error. 
Title: Re: Elvis is BACK!
Post by: DZ PLEASE on October 16, 2017, 12:00:51 PM
There is an ocean of difference between condemning someone of their past sins and correcting someones current error.
With all due miss/ma'am, your point is what exactly?

More to the point, who's the subject of your point and why?
Title: Re: Elvis is BACK!
Post by: Meg on October 16, 2017, 12:40:49 PM
Absolutely, we all have lived different degrees of sinful lives, and I would argue my degree would be the highest. Glory be to the mercy of God that we are able to still work.

Are you condemning others or defending God's law?

Let me ask you, if you told someone who was guilty of 1st degree murder that they would either get the death penalty or 25 years to life in jail would you be condemning them? Would you be judging them?


I'm only going to respond to the one question you asked..."Are you condemning others or defending God's law?"

My answer would be that I do defend God's law, but God is the one who has the ability to condemn in an absolute sense. I cannot say for certain that a soul in in Hell, even though it may be the most likely scenario (as in the case of Elvis). God is not going to pay any attention to what we may believe about the state of a particular soul at the time of death. Only He is privy to that knowlege regarding the state of a soul. Only God decides who will go to Hell, Heaven, or Purgatory. It isn't up to us.

However, a priest has the ability to decide whether to give extreme unction, or forgive sins, etc., when a person is preparing for death. So there is a human judgement involved, of course, at the time of death, or any other time, too. And of course, there are circuмstances when a fallen Catholic may not have a funeral Mass, or be buried in a Catholic cemetery. I certainly believe in that.

But my understanding is that the Church herself cannot say for certain that a particular soul in in Hell. It may be very likely, but not absolutely certain. Correct me if I'm wrong about that.

Upholding God's law doesn't give an absolute right to determine that a soul is in fact in Hell. Not in an absolute sense. I could be wrong, of course.
Title: Re: Elvis is BACK!
Post by: Last Tradhican on October 16, 2017, 02:03:47 PM

The Sacred Congregation of the Propagation of the Faith, under Pope Saint Pius X, in 1907, in answer to a question as to whether Confucius could have been saved, wrote:

 

“It is not allowed to affirm that Confucius was saved. Christians, when interrogated, must answer that those who die as infidels are damned”.
Title: Re: Elvis is BACK!
Post by: Nooseph Polten on October 16, 2017, 02:14:21 PM
If you believe he is in purgatory, the prayers need be directed towards you. The servant of Satan died face down with his pajamas around his ankles. Some claim he was reading a pornography book, which I would presume to believe since he was addicted to fornication.
Certainly didn't die in the odor of sanctity.
Would you please tell me where I will end up after death, o holy prophet of the predestined?
Title: Re: Elvis is BACK!
Post by: cassini on October 16, 2017, 02:58:31 PM

It was taught to me many times in my Catholic life that we do not KNOW if a certain person is in hell or not. By way of the teachings of our faith we do know how and why people go to hell for all eternity, but ultimately God judges every person individually. 

Douay-Rheims Bible (http://biblehub.com/drb/luke/6.htm)
Judge not, and you shall not be judged. Condemn not, and you shall not be condemned. Forgive, and you shall be forgiven.

Didn't He tell us not to judge, lest we should be judged for doing so? Only God knows everything and whereas probably most we knew who deserved hell are probably there anyway, I would not go public in judging someone like Elvis, a sinner like us all in his own way. But just as we HOPE God will forgive us, we can hope he forgave men like Elvis who had a troubled life that I am glad I did not have.  
Title: Re: Elvis is BACK!
Post by: DZ PLEASE on October 16, 2017, 03:16:54 PM
There are numerous distinction fails developing rapidly here.

One involves certitude, and its degrees.

Another involves the practical order.

The Church does not judge internal things, at least not directly.

Going by what is known, we can know at least to moral certainty whether we can or cannot, should or should not, for example,  consider someone lost.

You can see an example of this, for example, when S. Robert Bellarmine speaks of someone, in this instance a pope, being rightly condemned as a heretic when it was later determined that this pope was not actually a heretic.

You can see this kind of thinking somewhat paralleled in criminal convictions, at least in principle, where the case and evidence presented rightly leads to a conviction of someone who is innocent.

It would be wrong to not convict in that case.

There are other distinctions, but there is a reason why there are such things as theologians, philosophers, and books.

If you think about it, how else could things work? We can see the alternatives doing much damage to people's ability to see the visible Church for one.
Title: Re: Elvis is BACK!
Post by: DZ PLEASE on October 16, 2017, 03:24:31 PM

Douay-Rheims Bible (http://biblehub.com/drb/luke/6.htm)
Judge not, and you shall not be judged. Condemn not, and you shall not be condemned. Forgive, and you shall be forgiven.

Didn't He tell us not to judge, lest we should be judged for doing so? Only God knows everything and whereas probably most we knew who deserved hell are probably there anyway, I would not go public in judging someone like Elvis, a sinner like us all in his own way. But just as we HOPE God will forgive us, we can hope he forgave men like Elvis who had a troubled life that I am glad I did not have.  
Saying what God has said isn't saying it yourself.

There is no point, for example, of even telling us things like "Extra Ecclesiam, nulla salus est." if we can't know who is and isn't inside the Church and, conversely, outside the Church.

"Meaningless formula", at least as far as we're concerned.
Title: Re: Elvis is BACK!
Post by: DZ PLEASE on October 16, 2017, 03:54:34 PM
We are taught not to judge RASHLY.  So you do not understand.

A man and woman are walking down the street, to assume they are fornicators is to judge rashly.

A man and woman that are participating in lustful acts towards one and other in public, could be assumed as fornicators. This is not judging rashly.

Elvis is in hell because he didn't love Jesus, how do I know he didn't love Jesus?

If you love me, keep my commandments. John 14:15

He who saith that he knoweth him, and keepeth not his commandments, is a liar, and the truth is not in him. 1 John 2:4

The man condemned himself, not me.  He wasn't even Catholic.

That is all I will comment on this.
Here's another question, just for thought; if the cited scripture is to be taken as this person suggests, then how do we;

1. Examine ourselves and, subsequently
 1. Accuse ourselves and then,
  1. Submit ourselves to a priest for judgement?

What do we go to confession for then? What is the point? What is the big deal?

Related example two:

Is there anyone that we can think of who is the supreme judge over the court of final appeal here on earth?

Just what does or can this person judge anyway?

Saying where someone is heading isn't saying that they've arrived either.

Related example three:

Why is it that none get butt-hurt when someone is impromptu canonized, and by laymen no less? Isn't that judging too?

Again, just for consideration.

So much equivocation, conflation and lack of distinction, in the "trad" world and otherwise.

"Don't judge?"

"What prompted you to give such a command? So what if I do?"
Title: Re: Elvis is BACK!
Post by: 1st Mansion Tenant on October 16, 2017, 07:37:36 PM
Elvis was raised in Protestant Evangelism. He was an avid reader and probably examined Catholicism, and I believe may have toyed with the idea of converting, given the stories about Fr Balduc.   While his Christian roots ran deep, he was a complicated guy and ran astray into New Age and Eastern studies. The world loved him because he was handsome, talented and generous. But the truth is: he was also lonely, confused and self-centered, a womanizing adulterer and pill-popper. I hope by some miracle he might be in Purgatory, but I don't see how. If he is, well then, may God show such mercy for all of us.
Title: Re: Elvis is BACK!
Post by: Nadir on October 17, 2017, 05:38:53 AM
I said:

Quote
I don't understand who how you could wish him to be alive in this mess of a world With people going crazy.
 .

Thank you, Cassini, for a note of common sense and to ClemensMaria for the Hail Mary by Elvis, who sings that Mary is holding back her Son's hand.
 Makes me think that at worst Elvis is suffering in purgatory, so pray for him.

An Even Seven asked:

Quote
Does this mean that you think "at best" Elvis went directly to heaven at his death? Or do you think "at best" he's still alive?

And I replied:
Quote
No and No.

AES:
Quote
Nadir, I am not trying to nit-pick but you said "Makes me think that at worst Elvis is suffering in purgatory, so pray for him." This implies that best case scenario, Elvis went straight to heaven. Either way he lived and died, at least externally, as a non-Catholic and we are to assume he went to hell right? Just an explanation please.


As I said in my first post: “I don't understand how you (Tradplorable) could wish him to be alive in this mess of a world with people going crazy” it’s obvious I didn’t think "at best" he's still alive.
That’s the second NO.
.
Re the first NO, I did not think "at best" Elvis went directly to heaven at his death.  I expressed myself poorly. It should have been “Elvis, singing that Mary is holding back her Son's hand, makes me think that at worst Elvis is suffering in purgatory, so pray for him.