Send CathInfo's owner Matthew a gift from his Amazon wish list:
https://www.amazon.com/hz/wishlist/ls/25M2B8RERL1UO

Author Topic: A New Crusade  (Read 4114 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Re: A New Crusade
« Reply #20 on: June 26, 2017, 05:30:30 AM »

Quote
BEWARE OF ALEXIS BUGNOLO - DON'T GIVE THIS FRAUD YOUR MONEY

"Br." Alexis Bugnolo would have you believe that he is a Franciscan Friar, a traditional Catholic, an intellectual and deeply interested in the conflict in the middle east and other causes. Unfortunately non of this is true. Bugnolo set up a "house of formation in Rome" a few years ago and we got to know him quite well.

HE IS NOT A FRANCISCAN. He was ejected from the Franciscans of the Immaculate in the 1990s without vows, but he tells people that he is a Franciscan or when pressed an "independent Franciscan hermit with tactit approval from the Holy Father." That was abolished centuries ago. One cannot just abide by the rule of St. Francis and say that he is a Franciscan.

HE IS NOT AN INTELLECTUAL. He holds no degrees other than perhaps a BA.

THIS IS NOT HIS FIRST START-UP. Here in Rome Bugnolo's "house of formation" failed because Bugnolo could not get along with others. He received at least one young man for formation, but did not get along with him, and TURNED HIM OUT without appeal or due process. Of course there can be no due process with Bugnolo because he is not a part of the Chruch structure. The SSPX and even the extreme traditionalists have superiors and by-laws and constitutions. Bugnolo, however, lives life on a whim and everyone must follow his lead. Bugnolo also start the Scholasticuм, an online program for studying Thomistic Philosophy. It seems he bamboozled several professors, but as far as the website shows, no classes ever took place. Now Bugnolo has turned to Ordo Militaris as his new initiative by which he can garner some sense of legitimacy for his irregular life. He once hoped to start his own religious order, but given his mental instability, I hope he has realized that no one will ever grant him such authority and no one will follow him.

HE IS NOT A TRADITIONAL CATHOLIC. Bugnolo tells traddies that he is one of them whenever he can so that he can play the cleric and enjoy all their deference. In reality though Bugnolo attends the NO and communes with Bishops and monks that he ridicules. He'll claim that he is a traditionalist but he doesn't even say the traditional Divine Office!

Bugnolo has some rich family member who supports his pet projects. He has not distinguished himself in learning or piety. Please don't give this bozo your money and certainly DO NOT attempt to go fight with him in his imaginary army. For if you were ever to get to the front lines he would be onto his next project and leave you in the lurch just like he did to a young man in Rome. In your charity, starve the beast until he recognizes his own deceit and finally either retires to an actual Franciscan community or gets a day job to support himself without a Franciscan pretense. Supporting and enabling vagrant imposters is bad for the Catholic Church, and, if you do so knowingly, it is bad for your soul too.

Mike, you have some great programming. I'm sorry that you got cat-fished.

Re: A New Crusade
« Reply #21 on: June 26, 2017, 11:02:00 AM »
great Post.


Re: A New Crusade
« Reply #22 on: June 26, 2017, 07:39:27 PM »
Thank you Laramie!

Re: A New Crusade
« Reply #23 on: June 26, 2017, 09:46:59 PM »
Thank you Laramie!
I was having trouble typing into the whitespace on Cathinfo last night for whatever reason, so I could only copy and paste without an explanation.  

That comment came from one of the three videos--off of Youtube.  

So, who am I to believe.  This supposed friar?  Or a random charge in a comment box?  

I'm definitely investigating this.  If it's real, I am wanting to promote it.  I've tried calling the number, but there has been no answer thus far. 
 
If this guy were serious, you think he would try to make himself more accessible.  Regular Youtube videos discussing the importance of his initiative, an e-mail address you could write to if you had questions, or a Facebook page.  But no.  This guy is somewhat inaccessible and difficult to pin down.  Smells like a fraud.  Especially when I consider, how in his talks, he discusses how the organization could be funded in part through buying stocks of his organization.  

I'm afraid it's turning out to be a dud.  The idea is noble.  But this guy is putting a bad name on such an idea.  I'm going to continue to try to contact this friar.  I will put these accusations to him to see what he has to say to them.  

Re: A New Crusade
« Reply #24 on: June 26, 2017, 11:40:21 PM »


Honestly this seems like a great way to end up on an FBI watch list and perhaps waste your money and that's about it. To start lets take a step back and assess what a tremendous failure the original crusades were and back then the Crusaders had entire nations backing them and the authority of the papacy, they also had the Byzantine Empire to at least allow them to arrive safely. If this proposed Crusade takes place how will they arrive? I sincerely doubt any nation with an airport functioning is just going to allow you to land an army in their back yard. Couple that with none of these men knowing the region and are entirely unknown to the locals. Not to mention that foreign intervention has always since the dawn of time made the Middle East worse. If you honestly care about Christians in the Middle East you're better off flying into Egypt and try tracking down one of the already existing militia groups. 


The bottom line is this, a crusade involves a flood of foreigners into lands they do not know, to protect people that do not know them for a cause no one is sure of. Not to mention such an influx is likely to piss off local nations and the people. On top of these we live in a secular world and absolutely no secular power is going to allow you to get anything done. 

I hope this is nothing more than a feverish dream because any organized foreign Catholic Crusade is going to accomplish nothing but widowed wives and fatherless children. Your efforts would be better spent preaching at home and trying to revive the shadow that was Catholicism instead of going halfway across the world to wage an ill conceived campaign.