I started lurking on this forum when I read about SGG through Dr. Droleskey. I saw so many problems with Perez (another longstanding problem that I haven't touched on here, finally caused me to walk.) I felt so alone as most of the people there put up with him, or worse, - never even saw a problem. Misery loves company you know! As I've stated I wasn't the only one to leave in disgust, but I wasn't really friends with them - I just knew them or knew of them.
Anyway, after reading about SGG, CMRI, SSPV & experiencing OLHC, I'm beginning to agree more & more with those with a 'strict view on validity'. I also disagree with the poster here (Can't remember who) who writes about 'sentimental fiftyism'. My parents & all those I grew up with in the 50's were far from sentimental. They were down to earth, salt of the earth kind of people who were no-nonsense Catholics. They'd feel right at home with St. Peter I do believe, so I don't know what he's talking about. The ONE true church has been fractured into a thousand warring groups, so now we see Catholics fighting Catholics instead of the outside enemy - all the while going to church praying for UNITY! And no, I don't have the answer.
To get back to Perez - I was mainly referring to the different seminaries he was in & also the churches he pastored in Europe & why he left them all, or was he asked to leave? He seems to be mum on all that. I know about his ordination by Cardinal Stickler, but how & when did he meet the author of Absinthe??