As I figured...the same posters are avoiding the main issue here: that it is not proven that Honorius was condemned as a PUBLIC heretic. Public heretics lose membership in the Church and yes, if said posters believe in EENS, OUTSIDE THE CHURCH THERE IS NO SALVATION, then yes, they believe that Honorius must be in Hell.
If they aren't sure where he is, then perhaps they should re-consider their view on whether Honorius was a public heretic or EENS.
I'm done here.
You have no idea what you are even talking about.
Since you refuse to believe that per the the Council, he was a heretic and a pope at the same time, and instead you choose to dwell on his eternal fate - as if that is a matter you need to be curious or concerned about, then yes, you may as well be done here.
Actually, I think you know that I do know what I'm talking about. You're just avoiding the issue.
You think he is a public heretic based on the Council (despite the fact that you and others have yet to prove that it was public heresy he was guilty of). Public heretics are outside of the Church (private are not). Given you are so sure he is guilty of public heresy, and your being such a huge advocate for strict EENS, you know that he had to have died outside of the Church (he was anathematized AFTER his death). And yet you are unwilling to admit that that means he went to Hell.
So, either you really don't think he was guilty of public heresy OR you really don't believe in strict EENS.
No. YOU think heretics lose their office and are outside the Church - but the Council clearly disagrees with you. I agree with the Council because it is a Council of the Church and the Church has spoken that the pope was also a heretic and guilty of heresy - much to the dismay of sedevacantists because it completely blows their entire theory (and it is only a theory) right to smithereens.
What we DO KNOW is that IF, before he died, he received the Last Rites - and we have every reason to believe that a pope who died back in the 600s had a priest available to give him the Last Rites before he died, that he went straight to heaven.
THAT we can say. As we can say a baby who dies after receiving the sacrament went straight to heaven. And we can say a baby who died without the sacrament did not make it to heaven.
But even when it comes to the fate of Judas Iscariot, the Church has never judged him to be in hell because that is something we as Roman Catholics are not permitted to do.
We know that if he died without the last sacrament or prior to going to confession and died still in his heresy, that he, a pope, went to hell. But we could not and do not know and should not be curious about knowing.