CathInfo.com

Yes, Thank you to TKGS for looking that up for us.  I wish I had my copy since it would help me out with a few more things I have been looking into. If anyone is interested in reading this informative book, No Crisis in the Church? compiled by Simon Galloway you can find one at http://www.miqcenter.com/books/0-problems.shtml

To see a review on it go to:
http://www.traditioninaction.org/bkreviews/A_023br_CrisisInChurch_Somerville.htm

I got this book a couple years ago and couldn't put it down, even though it was disheartening for me to read how differently the past few Popes have taught on Catholic doctrines than the Popes before Vatican 2.  I loaned my book out and haven't seen it since, so I recently began searching for a used copy and wonder if it is out of print because the few copies that I found online are priced at $72.95 and up. (It makes me wonder if people who DON"T want us to read this have bought up copies but maybe that's being paranoid!)  In my search for this book, I then thought of the CMRI bookstore online and they have it listed new for $21.95 (see the above link). Has anyone else read this book?  

Quote from: Alexandria

Quote from: Dawn

sedes are gnostics? Ya okay how do they come up with that?

Yes, that is what the priest called them.  I printed out a copy of the email correspondence that the person had put on the now defunct forum.  That is what he called sedevacantists:  gnostics.

The priest said that they think they have a "secret knowledge".   :scared2:

He mistakes a private judgment based on public knowledge with a "secret  knowledge." He is confused.

Don't tell him that.  You'll knock down his sede sandcastle and he might have to look at the facts.  :wink:

Quote from: SpiritusSanctus

1.- The SSPX has been in talks for some time now. Don't you think that if they were negotiating, they would have already bought in to some agreement thrown out by Rome? When negotiating with Rome, their stance is pretty simple. "You have either this option or the other, take your pick." That's usually how it is.

It is not logical to assume they would have come to an agreement already.  We can say that the excommunications have been lifted and there is some shift in society rhetoric.

Quote

2.- Those catechism classes mean nothing in this particular discussion. Who really expected the SSPX to be just as good if not better without LeFebvre?

No, they have to do with the attitude that the society wants sspx goers to have towards the conciliar bishops: ie to defend them against the accusations in the abuse scandal.  

Quote

3.- Still not buying it. I think some of the extreme sedes went overboard when they first heard that the SSPX was in talks with Rome.

Not buying what? You said:

Quote

It's nothing more than a false rumor put out by a bunch of extreme sedes or extremists.

I showed you that it isn't just extreme sedes talking about it.  

You know it's rather amusing, many sspx priests and bishops are accused by NO types of being crypto-sedes.  Maybe the moment they are no longer in favor this will be a way to banish them, by suddenly discovering they must be sedes because they are saying the same things the society has always said, and you couldn't say those things without really being a sede.

bump