We've attracted a DOGMATIC SEDEVACANTIST and DOGMATIC HOME-ALONER here!

My real name: Rogelio Caballero.

My personal posture: Paul VI and his successors lack(ed) papal authority. NO orders must be considered invalid. A Mass where a false Pope is conmemorated is "tainted with sacrilege and the crime of capital schism" - Fr. Guérard des Lauriers. Episcopal consecrations without Apostolic mandate are an "offense against the unity of the Church" - Pope Pius XII, Ad Apostolorum Principis.

He thinks the whole Traditional Movement is not legitimate, because the various Trad bishops (+ABL, SSPX bishops, Sede bishops, etc.) didn't have Papal Mandate for their consecrations. See where this Una cuм nonsense leads?

The Traditional Movement is the answer. NOT staying at home for 60 years doing nothing but praying and waiting around for the Second Coming. We need Mass, we need the Sacraments.

The Catholic Faith is a habit of life. If you cease to practice the Catholic Faith, you will cease to be Catholic. It's simple. How can you stay Catholic without practicing your Faith for decades?

And don't give me that "Japanese Hidden Christians" nonsense. They were in VERY sad shape. They kept a faint memory of a couple basic dogmas (priestly celibacy, etc.) and not much more. I shudder to think how many of them lost their souls. Fr. Joseph Pfeiffer likes to quote the Hidden Christians because it goes well with his own Home Aloner agenda. The Hidden Christians are the "patron saint" of Home Aloners and Home Aloneism-promoters.

I have no respect OR devotion to these so-called "hidden Christians". Why would I? They weren't saints, they might have all gone to hell for all we know. We should NOT base our current actions on what these particular Japanese did, nor follow their path.

They used a Buddhist goddess statue, but secretly calling it Mary. But after centuries of using a Buddhist goddess statue, guess what happened? Many of them lost the Faith. THE FAITH IS A HABIT OF LIFE.

Yes- this is the only problem I have with certain Sede groups-
That they say a Resistance TLM Mass is is invalid because of "una-cuм".

They may have an option of saying it's illicit , but saying the entire Mass is invalid is really outside of their "wheelhouse" so to speak.
To me they have no authority to say a validly ordained Traditional priest is saying an invalid Tradition Mass because of naming "una cuм".


I don't like the una cuм either, but I will go to valid una cuм Masses with validly ordained priests.

Someone tell me where "una cuм" actually invalidates the Mass and where I can find this information, please.

Do you know the difference between illicit and invalid? I think you are confused.

I understand the point of the author in your blurb, but it doesn't explain the justification why "sedevacantists" have to go off and have their own chapels, keep to themselves, avoid associating with non-sedevacantist Traditional Catholics, etc.

It's a conclusion, yes. But not an infallible dogma. It's a private opinion at best. You don't condemn or shun others for having a different opinion from you.

It might start out as an opinion or theory, but it doesn't end there. Most often it morphs or evolves into an all necessary truth, a  dogmatic certainty, even for priests and bishops who should know better - and are expected to know better. 

I hope they are right.

From my observation, one cause of division is demonising the intentions of people with differing view points.

For example a non dogmatic sede accusing an sspxer of disagreeing with him because of dishonesty, pride, stubbornness or some other evil, and vice versa from sspxers to sedes.

When in reality they fail to consider that people may genuinely disagree with them in good faith. Some may disagree because they really see their argument as logically sound, whilst truly believing yours is irrational (even if they are wrong).

This reminds me of how the FE/GE discussions go. Any dogmatic FE's here?

I attend the Masses of Fr. David Hewko.  He doesn't share my positions regarding Leo XIV and Jorge Bergoglio.  He holds them as popes.

I encourage you to avoid Fr. Hewko. (The elder).