Author Topic: SSPX consecrations could mark new rupture within the Church. (Read 404 times)

AGeorge · « **Reply #10 on:** **Today** at 05:56:26 PM »

Quote from: Comrade on Today at 02:35:39 PM

Ignoring history is about the worst vantage point to entertain. Ignore someone's past unrecanted position and then ignoring the fact that Fellay is the trusted advisor of the superior general, is dangerous.

You are missing my entire point. I understand what you're saying. The poster is confused about what constitutes a rupture with the church. I was trying to speak to the points made in the original post. Delving into what led to the split in 2012 is not the issue. I agree that the positions of 2008 and 2012 need to be recanted, and I believe that the Doctrinal Preamble should be renounced as well.
No disagreement on those points...but it doesn't help educate the person about the issue at hand, namely the consecration of bishops which he wrongly believes will cause a rupture.

Plenus Venter · « **Reply #11 on:** **Today** at 06:21:40 PM »

Quote from: Telling on Today at 06:38:49 AM

One must respect the Pope, submit to him, and live in communion with him if one wants to go to Heaven. One can disagree here and there, but must disagree respectfully.

Common man! Disagree here and there?

For the last 60 years the Pope and his Conciliar Church have been diametrically opposed to the reign of Christ the King and the Immaculate Heart of Mary, doing everything possible, humanly speaking, to destroy it. And you would gather all the sheep into the wolves' den?

Tradition would not even exist today if Archbishop Lefebvre had've followed your advice. You need to understand what true submission of a subject means, what true obedience means.

You are an Indult Catholic? Why do you think you have an Indult Mass to even be able to refer to yourself as such?

CathInfo.com

Author Topic: SSPX consecrations could mark new rupture within the Church. (Read 404 times)

AGeorge

Re: SSPX consecrations could mark new rupture within the Church.

Plenus Venter

Re: SSPX consecrations could mark new rupture within the Church.