This is one of my biggest concerns, being new to tradition and just coming out the the NO Mass to the diocesan TLM. Why haven't more traditional Catholics called the the popes out? Why does the SSPX tippy toe around this issue? It is becoming apparent to me most of the church is no longer Catholic. Is it so difficult to say Christians are no longer found at the top of the church? For Benedict to go to a Jєωιѕн ѕуηαgσgυє and not tell them to convert is an act of apostasy isn't it?
I am not an expert on Catholicism, except to say I was seldom taught it, if ever, in all my years of Catholic schools and NO Masses.
Many of us non-sedes do "call the Pope out" as you say but we remain loyal to his office. The reason we do this is because we have seen too many times what happens to the sedes who break free from all control and try to govern themselves.
1) The sede groups end up as personality cults. Do a little reading about the man in my avatar, Bishop Francis Schuckardt, or about the Palmarian Catholic Church in Spain, or a sicko named Richard Ibranyi.
2) Sedes splinter into many different groups, each one excommunicating and anathematizing the other, like Pentecostals, Baptists, and Methodists do.
3) Scandals arise which no one has the authority to resolve, such as the situation we are seeing with the SGG in Ohio.
4) Sedevacantism is a dead-end mentality. The only way a Pope can be restored is if we are in the Last Days before the end of the world. If we are not in the final times now, then they are left adrift, with no mechanism for restoring the Church.
5)Sedevacantism is in and of itself a radical proposition. This radicalism grows and grows until it results in mentalities like those of some of the more vociferous posters on this forum, who accept no authority higher than their own consciences and their own private interpretations of Church docuмents. Since they can find no one to agree with them, and they believe, in the style of little kids on the playground that they will somehow get "cooties" from those who don't agree with them on every single point, they are unable to form a community of any kind and are cut off from the reception of the Sacraments and assistance at a Mass. The end result for them is increasing isolation, radicalism, and either mental illness or a lonely death in rebellion.