Steve seems to be a particularly damaged person. When I think back on my Catholic past and upbringing I can only think just how rich and wonderful it was, and how much a younger person born into and raised in the post conciliar church has missed. Also, His memories seem overwhelmingly negative. Being the oldest boomer here mine are all positive. I am thankful for a faith based, not on rules and a threatening god-figure but on a loving and merciful Saviour and Friend. My heart goes out to him and others with his experiences and worse.
There is much truth in this quote:
... I have gradually come to realize that if the post-conciliar Church I grew up in isn’t really Catholicism, traditionalism isn’t either. Instead, it is an ideological mask more identifiably in the shape of true Catholicism. It is, in some respects, a long-running Live Action Roleplay — a LARP — in which participants act out what they think Catholicism looked like in “the good old days” while perpetually running down any kind of Catholicism (or Catholic who practices it) that isn’ttraditionalism. But it is essentially an affectation; an attempt to reconstruct and live within a historical context that no longer exists. Traditional Catholicism does exist, in the sense that all history exists. The Traditional Catholic liturgy exists not just historically, but even now. But traditionalism, as a “movement ...
It’s not a historical reality, because it is merely a reaction to a modern innovation.
There is no going back. As the song goes: onward Christian soldiers. Whatever the future holds for us, we don’t know. Nevertheless to whom shall we go? Steve needs our prayer to come through this crisis.