Does the Society recognize the Thuc consecrations? Does Rome?
Last I heard, they were considered doubtful, or at least some of them were.
Can you post correspondence from the Vatican that states this? As for the "Society", what they think of the Thuc consecrations is of no interest to me.
So because you personally don't like the SSPX, you're prepared to throw out their collective expertise on Ordination? What makes you think they're so petty that they'd deny the validity of Thuc ordinations just because Thuc-line bishops/priests aren't part of the SSPX?
So many people have a *very* narrow view and experience of the SSPX. They go on very thin anecdotal evidence at best.
And no, spending a number of years at a single SSPX chapel doesn't count as a ton of experience. No more than I could call myself a "widely traveled man" if I spent 50 years living in my hometown. I might be an expert at my hometown -- but not other places.
Some people have a bad experience with a few parishioners, or an individual priest, and then throw out the baby with the bath water. "The whole group is rotten!" How rational is that? That's a very emotional way to behave.
So
if I can come up with one example of a woman having loose morals, I can conclude that all women are sluts? That is the *exact same logic* as the person who fights with an SSPX priest, leaves the congregation, and spends his remaining days bashing the SSPX.
What is wrong with some people?
Matthew