Send CathInfo's owner Matthew a gift from his Amazon wish list:
https://www.amazon.com/hz/wishlist/ls/25M2B8RERL1UO

Author Topic: Resisting An Infallible Pope?  (Read 1044 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Re: Resisting An Infallible Pope?
« Reply #35 on: Yesterday at 05:42:15 PM »
Because of the mental retardation and mind rot that is dogmatic sedevacantism, I find myself having to explain things yet again.

You obligation is to first and foremost keep the faith.

You do what Catholics have always done. When something appears to not be Catholic you stay away. Not making judgements about the personal salvation of that person and not making judgments about high theological matters such as the depostion of a Pope.

you just stay away. That is all God asks us to do.

He does not ask us to "Go forth and convert on the internet everyone to sedevacantism!". He does not say "you are the greatest person ever for figuring out that the Pope is not the Pope!".

Folks, get a grip. Really.

Re: Resisting An Infallible Pope?
« Reply #36 on: Yesterday at 05:44:14 PM »
Sedes fuel of gaslighting others. Being so cantankerous that others eventually cave in.

Sneering is another tactic. Very frequent here.

but they can never get away from their cryptonite which is Thuc and the 400+ Bishop madness.


Online Angelus

  • Supporter
Re: Resisting An Infallible Pope?
« Reply #37 on: Yesterday at 05:56:53 PM »
Because of the mental retardation and mind rot that is dogmatic sedevacantism, I find myself having to explain things yet again.

You obligation is to first and foremost keep the faith.

You do what Catholics have always done. When something appears to not be Catholic you stay away. Not making judgements about the personal salvation of that person and not making judgments about high theological matters such as the depostion of a Pope.

you just stay away. That is all God asks us to do.

He does not ask us to "Go forth and convert on the internet everyone to sedevacantism!". He does not say "you are the greatest person ever for figuring out that the Pope is not the Pope!".

Folks, get a grip. Really.


1. Yes, your first obligation is to keep the faith. 

2. Next, you follow St. Paul's instruction to Titus. Avoid heretics. This will help you keep the faith. But if you think a heretic is the leader of the Catholic Church, the Vicar of Christ, then you are putting your soul in jeopardy and scandalizing the weak-minded. 

3. If a heretic cannot be a Catholic and if we are to avoid him (Titus), then he is certainly not "the Holy Father." But if you insist on calling him "the Holy Father" then you are not following what St. Paul said to Titus and you may very well lose your faith from your stubbornness.

4. And, God certainly does not ONLY ask us to "stay away." We are called to be "martyrs." Martyrs testify to the truth and help their brothers and sisters understand the spiritual danger surrounding them. This is called charity. 

Re: Resisting An Infallible Pope?
« Reply #38 on: Yesterday at 06:05:40 PM »

1. Yes, your first obligation is to keep the faith.

2. Next, you follow St. Paul's instruction to Titus. Avoid heretics. This will help you keep the faith. But if you think a heretic is the leader of the Catholic Church, the Vicar of Christ, then you are putting your soul in jeopardy and scandalizing the weak-minded.

3. If a heretic cannot be a Catholic and if we are to avoid him (Titus), then he is certainly not "the Holy Father." But if you insist on calling him "the Holy Father" then you are not following what St. Paul said to Titus and you may very well lose your faith from your stubbornness.

4. And, God certainly does not ONLY ask us to "stay away." We are called to be "martyrs." Martyrs testify to the truth and help their brothers and sisters understand the spiritual danger surrounding them. This is called charity.


heresy is something the Church judges. Not individuals. The church decides whether bodies of beliefs are heresy. The Church determines what is heretical belief.

VII produced Neo modernism. It is not the same as the modernism as the modernism of St. Pius X.

We will wait for the condemnation of the Church of this new heresy.

In the meantime we just stay away. And stop making yourself Pope.

Re: Resisting An Infallible Pope?
« Reply #39 on: Yesterday at 06:06:34 PM »
Dogmatic sedes are so clearly mentally retarded because I have met virtually none of them who can tell me any of the tenets of neo modernism. and how it differs to classic modernism.