Hobble,
Have you seen Duddy's response to Omlor's position on the validity of the NOM?
www.catholicintl.com/catholicissues/noorvalid.pdf
Ah, before I could respond on the other thread you made the wise choice of discussing this topic on its own thread, as the question discussed on the other one is regarding the infallibility and primacy of the Roman Pontiff as defined by the Vatican Council and its pertinence to the present day crisis of the Church.
I have not read that particular article. It looks interesting. I'll have to wait to see if I get a chance to read it.
I'm also glad this is another thread because here you can continue the exchange you began with Eamon at the other thread (as this is relevant to the objections of Mr. Duddy).
I have to remind myself to start calling you guys by honorific terms (Mr., Mrs., Ms., etc.) because I do not know whether or not I am your junior.